Trump’s incredible 180 on OPEC, oil and free markets

President Donald Trump has long cast OPEC as an evil force ripping Americans off by not pumping enough oil. Now he’s pleading with Saudi Arabia and Russia to stop pumping so much oil.

In the past, Trump has called OPEC a “monopoly” (it’s not) that must be broken up. “They are robbing our country blind,” he tweeted in November 2012.

Since winning the presidency, Trump has repeatedly hammered OPEC for engineering higher oil prices to hurt American drivers.

“OPEC, please relax and take it easy. World cannot take a price hike – fragile!” the president tweeted in February 2019.

Flash forward to 2020: Instead of slamming OPEC for artificially restraining production, Trump is urging the cartel to do just that.

And rather than calling for OPEC to be broken up, Trump is elevating the group’s status by encouraging it to stop the oil crash – one that threatens to set off a surge of bankruptcies and job losses in Texas and throughout America’s oil industry.

Trump is even attempting to broker an agreement between Saudi Arabia and Russia to end their devastating price war by massively cutting production. The president’s tweets on the subject Thursday helped US oil prices to spike 25% – their biggest one-day gain in history.

“It’s amazing to have Trump get in the middle of this,” Helima Croft, head of global commodity strategy at RBC Capital Markets, told CNN Business. “Think about the 180: For years, Trump hated collusion among the producers and wanted to get rid of OPEC.”

Texas is a huge prize in 2020

That reversal reflects shifting political realities. The coronavirus pandemic is causing millions of job losses ahead of the November presidential election. A prolonged downturn in the US oil industry would only amplify the economic pain, especially in Republican-leaning states.

“What has changed is the political equation: Donald Trump cannot win reelection without Texas. It’s as simple as that,” said Greg Valliere, chief US policy strategist at AGF Investments.

Fuel pumps stand outside a Casey's General Stores Inc. gas station in Princeton, Illinois, U.S., on Wednesday, April 1, 2020. Even with the combination of some Canadian pullback, stripper wells going offline and announced shale cuts, that may not be enough to stop?oil prices from going lower as demand craters and supply from?OPEC?means major increases in stockpiles in the second quarter. Photographer: Daniel Acker/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Related article Oil prices spike by a record 25% as Trump talks up huge production cuts and Saudi Arabia calls for OPEC meeting

Not only is Texas the second-biggest electoral prize (after California), it’s also by far the nation’s largest oil producer. In fact, Texas pumps more oil than every OPEC nation not named Saudi Arabia.

But Texas is getting crushed by cheap oil. Russia, seeking to blunt the rise of US shale oil producers, refused last month to cut oil production. Saudi Arabia responded by surging output and slashing prices.

Reflecting the urgency of the moment, Trump is meeting with the CEOs of ExxonMobil (XOM), Chevron and other leading US oil companies Friday to discuss the crisis facing the industry.

Navigating this situation is a delicate balance. The White House doesn’t want oil bankruptcies and job losses on its hands. But Trump doesn’t want to be seen helping oil CEOs and Saudi Arabia at the expense of average Americans who want cheap gas prices.

‘I would always raise hell with OPEC’

The president has acknowledged his evolving views.

“You always get a little torn,” Trump said on March 20. “Until we became the leading producer, I was always for the person driving the car and filling up the tank of gas…If (prices were too high, I would always raise hell with OPEC.”

Now the oil crash is setting off real turmoil in the energy industry. Whiting Petroleum (WLL), a former rising star in the shale industry, this week became the first of what will surely be a wave of US oil companies to file for bankruptcy during this crisis.

Nearly 100 US oil and gas producers could file for Chapter 11 over the next year, Buddy Clark, co-chair of the energy practice at Houston law firm Haynes and Boone, told CNN Business.

And that may be the optimistic view.

Rystad Energy warned this week that 140 US oil producers could file for bankruptcy this year if oil stays at $20 a barrel, followed by another 400 in 2021.

Even the largest oil companies are cutting back. Debt-ridden Occidental Petroleum (OXY) slashed its dividend by 86% and announced pay cuts across the entire company. Chevron (CVX) is cutting production and spending in hopes of avoiding its first dividend cut since the Great Depression.

“We have a great oil industry, and the oil industry is being ravaged,” Trump said Wednesday during a press briefing. “We don’t want to lose our great oil companies.”

Will Texas cap output?

Now there is a debate playing out over whether and even how the United States should intervene in the oil war.

Some independent oil producers are pushing Texas to – for the first time in more than 40 years – limit the state’s output.

Flare stacks beside two oilfield pumpjacks, belonging to Whiting Oil & Gas Corp., producing crude on wells in the Bakken Formation (Williston Basin) near Ray, ND on Sat., Sept. 8, 2018. (Larry MacDougal via AP)

Related article A wave of oil bankruptcies is on the way

Ryan Sitton, a commissioner on the Railroad Commission of Texas, the state’s energy regulator, even held a call Thursday with Russia’s energy minister to discuss options.

“While we normally compete,” Sitton said in a tweet, “we agreed that #COVID19 requires unprecedented levels of int’l cooperation.” He added that he will speak to Saudi Arabia’s energy minister soon.

Shale pioneer Harold Hamm and others are pushing for Trump, the self-proclaimed “Tariff Man,” to sanction OPEC by enacting tariffs that would punish Russia and Saudi Arabia for their ruinous oil war. But the American Petroleum Institute, the nation’s largest oil lobby, is urging Trump to avoid intervening in free markets.

Trump has so far taken modest steps, including instructing the Energy Department to take advantage of cheap prices by filling up the nation’s emergency stockpile of crude.

Debate over free markets

OPEC has signaled it isn’t willing to keep cutting production – unless other countries join in and do so, too.

The cartel will meet via video conference Monday with Russia and other countries outside the alliance, two sources at the OPEC secretariat told CNN Business. Although the final list of invitees has not yet been set, the United States, Canada and Mexico could reportedly be invited.

But it’s not clear how the United States would enact its own production cuts. US output is controlled by thousands of different companies across the nation who all have their own competing interests.

The irony calling on OPEC to come to the rescue is that Trump and others for years have complained that OPEC distorts free markets.

And Now that Saudi Arabia and Russia have stopped artificially restraining their production, they’re being urged to step back in to calm markets.

“This is the free market. We are living in the world of NOPEC right now,” RBC’s Croft said. “OPEC’s cuts gave US producers a vital lifeline. Now that the lifeline has been withdrawn, you have figures in Washington wanting sanctions against OPEC.”