CDC report says people in four key cities are listening to stay at home orders

People in four key cities are listening to orders to stay home, according to a report issued Monday by the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

“When you put in these social distancing measures, they do seem to work,” said study coauthor Kathleen Ethier, leader of the CDC’s community mitigation task force for the Covid-19 response.

While there are early indications that social distancing has helped slow the spread of the coronavirus, experts warn that if people don’t continue to adhere to the orders, the virus could surge again in some areas.

The CDC report looked at data in New York City, Seattle, New Orleans and San Francisco, four cities with substantial numbers of coronavirus patients early in the outbreak that mandated stay at home orders in mid- to late-March.

Paramedics of the Santa Rita ambulance service wear personal protective equipment (PPE) as they present an improvised isolation capsule and an ambulance adapted to transfer patients with the novel coronavirus COVID-19, in Cali, Colombia, on April 7, 2020. - The coronavirus pandemic has killed more than 75,000 people worldwide since it emerged in China in December, according to a tally compiled by AFP from official sources at 0945 GMT on Tuesday. (Photo by Luis ROBAYO / AFP) (Photo by LUIS ROBAYO/AFP via Getty Images)

Related article Covid-19 numbers show promise, but health experts warn each state is a different battleground

It found that, in all four places, close to 80% of people were leaving home on February 26. And by April 1, that declined between 20 percentage points and 40 percentage points in each city, with mobility decreasing each time a new social distancing order was issued, starting with bans on mass gatherings, and then later restaurant and school closures and finally stay at home orders.

“They didn’t leave their home at any point for any reason. They didn’t go outside. That’s significant,” Ethier said.

The CDC tracked mobility by looking at whether devices such as cell phones were brought more than 500 feet from the places they usually spend the night. Using anonymized publicly available data from a company called SafeGraph, the CDC looked at phones, tablets and watches belonging to between 3.6% and 6.4% of the population in each city.

That means anyone who just took a walk during the day would be counted as not staying at home.

An indication stay at home orders work

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA - MARCH 25: A man crosses the unusually quiet Hollywood Boulevard near the shuttered Pantages Theatre as the coronavirus pandemic continues on March 25, 2020 in Los Angeles, California. California Governor Gavin Newsom issued a 'stay at home' order for California's 40 million residents, with exceptions for essential activities, in order to slow the spread of COVID-19. (Photo by Mario Tama/Getty Images)

Related article What California is doing right in responding to the coronavirus pandemic

The report noted that more research would be needed to determine whether the stay at home policies had an impact on the spread of the virus, but already there have been some indicators that they’ve helped.

San Francisco issued the nation’s first shelter in place order on March 16, restricting all but essential activities.

The city has not seen the expected surge of coronavirus patients, and hospitals have not had difficulty coping with large numbers of emergency room visits or stays in the intensive care unit.

“If I had to attribute it to one thing, it has to be [San Francisco] Mayor London Breed’s foresight in calling state of emergency early, getting people to shelter in place early, and really just wonderful messaging of social distancing,” said Dr. Jahan Fahimi, an emergency room physician at University of California San Francisco.

The rise in the numbers of coronavirus patients in New York is starting to slow, and officials attribute that in part to the state’s stay at home order, which was issued March 22.

“We’re seeing a rather dramatic decrease in the need for hospitalizations,” said Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute for Allergies and Infectious Diseases. “That means that what we are doing is working and therefore we need to continue doing it.”

CDC Director Dr. Robert Redfield said the most powerful weapon against coronavirus is social distancing rules, which calls for people stay at least 6 feet apart from each other.

“We’re not defenseless,” Redfield said during CNN’s coronavirus town hall Thursday. “This virus has a very significant weakness – it can’t swim seven feet.”

So when can we all get out of the house?

President Donald Trump’s aides have begun intensive discussions on a plan to reopen the US economy as early as the start of May, according to people familiar with the deliberations.

“Some areas are much less affected than others,” Trump said Wednesday at a White House briefing. “But it would be nice to be able to open with a big bang and open up our country or certainly most of our country.”

Seattle policemen wearing protective gauze face masks during influenza epidemic of 1918 which claimed millions of lives worldwide (Photo by Time Life Pictures/National Archives/The LIFE Picture Collection via Getty Images)

Related article In the 1918 flu pandemic, not wearing a mask was illegal in some parts of America. What changed?

But experts – including those whom the White House has consulted – are more cautious.

On Sunday, Fauci said it was difficult to predict, but re-opening the economy “could probably start at least in some ways maybe next month.”

He added that the nation could not at one time drop the various restrictions put in place or there is an “extraordinary risk” of another major outbreak.

“We are hoping that by the end of the month we can look around and say, OK, is there any element here that we can safely and cautiously start pulling back on? If so, do it. If not, then just continue to hunker down,” Fauci said.

To help see where the outbreak is headed, the White House has consulted with various groups that are doing disease modelling, including the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of Washington.

“Some states, it’s possible in May,” Dr. Christopher Murray, director of the institute, told CBS Face The Nation on Sunday. “But in other states it’s going to be very, very unlikely that that would not lead to an immediately resurgence.”

In the decision about when to reopen the country, public health concerns might conflict with economic concerns.

“It’s an agonizing debate that is going on at the city, state, and national level for which there are no good answers. There are no good numbers to indicate when to start, in a staged, graduated fashion, easing up on social distancing,” said Dr. William Schaffner, an infectious disease expert and longtime adviser to the CDC. “But I do think if we ease up now, it would spike back up again before the summer. That clearly would happen.”

CNN’s Dr. Minali Nigam, Dan Simon, Kevin Liptak, Nicole Chaves and Madeline Holcombe contributed to this report.