Editors’ picks: 40 of our favorite Valentine’s Day gifts of all time

I spotted these sparkly rings while holiday shopping with my boyfriend last year, and he followed through and got them for me. They come as a trio, which is great value for under $70. You can stack the rings or wear each of them separately, so it’s really like you’re getting three rings for the price of one. I’ve added them to my assortment of everyday jewelry and love how pretty they look. (And if you’re wondering where the ring on my pointer finger in the picture is from, it’s the Verden Ring from Oma the Label.) — Sophie Shaw, associate beauty editor?

I am by no means a Watch Guy, but I love the classic, timeless look of this Seiko and am constantly getting compliments on it. Apparently, it looks a lot like a much, much more expensive watch, which was just a surprise bonus I discovered after wearing it out. I gave this watch to myself over three years ago, and it’s still holding up great. Plus, it’s solar-powered so you won’t worry about the battery dying.?— Daniel Rathburn, programming editor?

After eight years together, my fiancé and I don't usually get each other Valentine's Day gifts anymore. But in our early years of dating, I got us matching underwear from MeUndies — and we always talk about how unique of a gift it was. They come in tons of styles and patterns, so it's really fun picking out a design that speaks to you as a couple. Ours were pink with donuts all over! — Amina Lake Abdelrahman, home and gifts editor

My husband and I love being handy around the house, but operating heavy machinery to tackle serious tasks can be kind of intimidating. Knowing I gravitate toward anything pink, my husband gifted me this Barbie-coded home tool kit for Valentine’s Day that actually makes me excited about helping out with minor repairs. Best of all, a portion of proceeds goes toward funding breast cancer research. — Marissa Miller, contributing editor

We gave up making Valentine’s Day reservations decades ago but still have no interest in cooking for the big night —?which is why I’ve already ordered this Hancock Gourmet Lobster Co. Dinner from the upscale delivery service Goldbelly. I love that you can pick from diverse restaurants across the country and get everything packed in ice and ready to throw in the oven. I can’t wait to dig into this Maine seafood feast for two, including clam chowder, lobster pot pies and heavenly dulce de leche cakes. No muss, no fuss and no cooking. — Tobey Grumet Segal, reviews editor?

Eagle-eyed fans of Underscored’s practical gift guide series may have noticed that red coffee makers often make an appearance — and you’re about to find out why! A million years ago, give or take a millennium, I was given a red coffee maker for Valentine’s Day. It was such a clever and unexpected gift and it was so incredibly useful that it stayed with me in both the literal and figurative sense, eventually serving as the inspiration for all those practical gift guides you enjoy on this site.?— Jolie Kerr, contributor

My boyfriend got me this jacket when we first started going out, as he was obviously trying to impress me — such a big purchase for Valentine’s Day. Needless to say, it worked! I absolutely love it and get so many compliments on it. It’s still going strong nine years later and, in fact, gets better with age. — Rachel Quigley, managing editor

I love the idea of gifting this palette for Galentine’s or even as a pre-dinner V-day gift so your boo can use it to get ready for date night. It includes highlighter, blush and bronzer for a gorgeous, illuminated glow. Each of the shades glides on seamlessly and the pearlescent pigments reflect the light and enhance the features beautifully. It’s become an everyday product for me. — Sophie Shaw, associate beauty editor?

If your valentine is a wine fan, Juliet is my new favorite brand that takes the humble boxed wine and turns it up a notch. You can take it on the go for a romantic picnic, and the box is so pretty you don’t have to waste money on a gift bag. — Lindsey Smith, associate editor?

This luxurious gift set is one of the best things I’ve ever received. It truly will make your recipient feel like a million dollars. This set comes with body wash and body oil. The scent (and feel) is so dreamy. It’s the perfect gift for someone who values self-care and likes to be pampered.?— Lindsey Smith, associate editor

Without sounding cliché, I do feel that there must be something bubbly on Valentine’s Day. I love this mid-priced Blanc de Blancs sparkler because it’s made solely from Chardonnay grapes and it hails from a CA-based female- and black-owned winery. Forgo the big-name Champagnes this year and take a moment to savor this light, citrus-forward wine — which also happens to be the brand’s first single-vineyard, single-vintage sparkling wine in their reserve portfolio.?— Tobey Grumet Segal, reviews editor?

I gave my girlfriend these earrings last year and she wears them all the time.?The subtle, elegant look makes them perfect for everyday wear and I’m admittedly a bit too satisfied with myself whenever she gets compliments (which is not infrequent). Plus, for my fellow procrastinators, they are shipped quickly and securely via DHL.?— Daniel Rathburn, programming editor?

This candy is a great gift for anyone with a sweet tooth. Sugarfina teamed up with Chopin Vodka for a match made in heaven. If your valentine is a candy snob, these gummy bears are an elevated take on the classic candy we all loved as kids.?— Lindsey Smith, associate editor

We often have fondue for at-home date nights, but two years ago, I wanted to switch things up so I bought this mini heart-shaped waffle maker right before Valentine’s Day. We used it to make heart-shaped dark chocolate waffles (topped with strawberries and whipped cream!) for dessert on Feb. 14, and have since used it countless more times. — Amina Lake Abdelrahman, home and gifts editor

If you’re anything like me, then you love celebrating Galentine’s Day with your girls on Valentine’s Day. This new e.l.f Camo Liquid Blush is the perfect gift (and a great dupe for the Rare Beauty blush). You get a lot of product for such a small price. — Gabriella Triolo, social coordinator

My all-time favorite jewelry designer has a store just a few blocks from my Brooklyn apartment, which means my husband knows exactly where to go for Valentine’s Day. Alexis Bittar is known for his statement pieces, which, though hoarded by celebs as diverse as Michelle Obama, Meghan Markle, Kim Kardashian and Rita Ora, are still strangely affordable for us normies. And I adore this super-fly fluorescent-pink Lucite ring my husband gifted me last year — even though it’s currently 50% off! Tell your loved one now, or better yet, go nab it online in eight groovy colors before the sale is over.?— Tobey Grumet Segal, reviews editor?

I try to live a dairy-free lifestyle, so when I received these oat milk chocolates from my boyfriend last Valentine’s Day, I was ecstatic. They taste just like the original chocolates (if not better) and have become a necessity for every major holiday. If your loved one is lactose-free or vegan, this is the perfect chocolate for them this year. — Gabriella Triolo, social coordinator?

The sleek design of this diffuser fits in effortlessly with any home decor. While it may be subtle on a shelf, the smell carries throughout the whole house. I’d recommend gifting this with a few scents, like Maldives Escape and Amalfi Bliss. —?Lindsey Smith, associate editor?

I had been looking for a good, reliable, inexpensive lip balm for such a long time. I tried out the Super Balm from EOS and fell in love. The colors also make for the perfect Valentine’s gift for a significant other, friends or even yourself! — Gabriella Triolo, social coordinator

I’ll preface by saying, only gift people activewear if they’ve hinted at it or you know they love it. I’m completely obsessed with this Reformer onesie because it is incredibly comfortable while still having great compression. I love wearing it while doing yoga, and it’s also an easy travel outfit once you throw on a cozy sweater. — Lindsey Smith, associate editor?