Mike Pence and Kamala Harris faced off in the only general election vice presidential debate of 2020. They sparred over Trump’s coronavirus response, climate change, police reform and the Supreme Court.
They were separated by acrylic glass barriers and given a distance of 12 feet.
Fact check: CNN holds elected officials and candidates accountable by pointing out what’s true and what’s not. Follow our latest fact checks and context of the debate.?
Our live coverage has ended. Watch and read below to see how the event unfolded.
75 Posts
Here are some key lines from the first and only 2020 vice presidential debate
Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris and Vice President Mike Pence wave before the vice presidential debate on Wednesday, October 7, at Kingsbury Hall on the campus of the University of Utah in Salt Lake City.
Patrick Semansky/AP
The vice presidential debate between Mike Pence and Kamala Harris has wrapped. The candidates debated for 90 minutes about several topics, including coronavirus, the economy, foreign policy, race and police reform.
Harris?made history tonight, becoming the first Black and South Asian woman to participate in a general?election debate.
If you are just reading in, here are some key moments from the showdown:?
On President Trump’s taxes:
Harris: “Just so everyone is clear, when we say in debt, it means you owe money to somebody. It would be really good to know who the President of the United States, the commander-in-chief, owes money to,” Harris said. “Because the American people have a right to know what is influencing the President’s decisions. And is he making those decisions on the best interests of the American people, of you, or self-interest?”
Pence: “The American people have a?President who a businessman, a?job creator.?He’s paid tens of millions of?dollar in taxes, payroll,?property taxes.?Creating tens of thousands of?American jobs.?The President said the reports?are not accurate.?The President’s also released stacks of?financial disclosures, the?American people can review just?as the law allows,” the vice president said.
On the coronavirus vaccine:
Pence: “The fact that you continue to undermine public confidence in a vaccine, if a vaccine emerges during the Trump administration, I think is unconscionable,” Pence said. “Senator, I just ask you, stop playing politics with people’s lives.”
Harris: “If Dr. Fauci, if the doctors?tell us that we should take it,?I’ll be the first in line to?take it.?Absolutely,” Harris said. “But if Donald Trump tells us to?take it, I’m not taking it.”
On adding seats to the Supreme Court:
Pence: “This is a classic case of, if you can’t win by the rules, you’re going to change the rules,” Pence said, turning to Harris and asking directly if she and Biden were “going to pack the Supreme Court to get your way?”
Harris: “Joe and I are very clear: The American people are voting right now. And it should be their decision about who will serve on (the court) … for a lifetime,” she said.
On police violence and the death of Breonna Taylor:
Harris: “I’ve talked with Breonna’s?mother and her family, and her?family deserves justice.?She was a beautiful young woman,” Harris said. “Bad cops are bad for good cops.?We need reform of policing in?America and our criminal justice?system. That’s why Joe and I will?immediately ban choke holds and?carotid holds.”
Pence: “[T]he family of Breonna Taylor?has our sympathies.?But I trust our justice system,” Pence said. “This presumption that you?hear from Joe Biden and Kamala?Harris that America is?systemically racist, and as Joe?Biden said, he believes that law?enforcement has an implicit bias?against minorities, it’s a great?insult to the men and women who?serve in law enforcement.”
On trade:
Harris: “The vice president earlier said?it’s what he thinks as an?accomplishment that the?President’s trade war with?China,” Harris said. “You lost that trade war.?You lost it.?What ended up happening is?because of a so-called trade war?with China, America lost 300,000?manufacturing jobs.”
Pence: “Lost the trade war with China??Joe Biden never fought it,” he said.
On climate change:
Harris: “Let’s talk about who is prepared to lead our country over the course of the next four years on what is an existential threat to us as human beings. Joe is about saying, ‘We’re going to invest in renewable energy,’ it’s going to be about the creation of millions of jobs, we will achieve zero emissions by 2050, carbon neutral by 2035. Joe has a plan,” Harris said.
Pence: “There are no more hurricanes today than there were 100 years ago, but many climate alarmists use hurricanes and fires to try and sell the Green New Deal,” Pence said.
Link Copied!
CNN Instant Poll: Harris seen as winner in a debate that matched expectations
From CNN's Jennifer Agiesta
Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris waves as she arrives on stage for the vice presidential debate with Vice President Mike Pence on Wednesday, Oct. 7, at Kingsbury Hall on the campus of the University of Utah in Salt Lake City.
Julio Cortez/AP
More Americans said Sen. Kamala Harris did the best job in the vice presidential debate tonight, according to a CNN Instant Poll of registered voters who watched. About six in 10 (59%) said Harris won, 38% said Vice President Mike Pence had the better night.
Those results roughly match voters’ expectations heading in to the debate. In interviews conducted before tonight’s debate, 61% of these same voters said they expected Harris to win, 36% thought Pence would.?
Harris did improve her favorability rating among those who watched, according to the poll, while for Pence, the debate was a wash. In pre-debate interviews, 56% said they had a positive view of Harris, that rose to 63% after the debate. For Pence, his favorability stood at 41% in both pre- and post-debate interviews.?
Both candidates who took the stage tonight are broadly seen as qualified to be president: 65% said Pence is qualified to serve as president should that become necessary, 63% said the same about Harris.?
The CNN post-debate poll was conducted by SSRS by telephone and includes interviews with 609 registered voters who watched the Oct. 7 vice presidential debate. Results among debate-watchers have a margin of sampling error of plus or minus 5.3 percentage points. Respondents were originally interviewed Sept. 30 to Oct. 4 either by telephone or online, and indicated they planned to watch the debate and would be willing to be re-interviewed when it was over. Respondents initially reached online are members of the SSRS Opinion Panel, a nationally representative probability-based panel.
President Trump and Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden reacted on Twitter to their running mates’ vice presidential debate.
Trump and Biden are set to debate again next week in the second presidential debate.
See their tweets:
Link Copied!
Here's what undecided voters thought about the debate tonight
From CNN's Maureen Chowdhury
Following tonight’s vice presidential debate, a panel of undecided voters spoke with CNN’s Sara Sidner about what they thought of each candidate’s performance.
When the group was asked specifically to choose a winner between California Sen. Kamala Harris or Vice President Mike Pence, it was a tie; four thought Harris won, four thought Pence won and the rest thought the debate was a wash.
Fact check: Pence falsely claims mail-in voting creates a "massive opportunity for voter fraud"
From CNN's Paul P. Murphy and Marshall Cohen?
Vice President Mike Pence?claimed that universal mail-in voting leads to widespread fraud.?
“President Trump and I are fighting every day in courthouses to prevent Joe Biden and Kamala Harris from changing the rules and creating this universal mail-in voting that will create a massive opportunity for voter fraud,” Pence said.??
Numerous studies have found that mail-in voting does not lead to “massive” fraud. Furthermore, only nine states and Washington, DC, are using “universal mail-in voting” this year.?
Experts acknowledge there might be some logistical issues in terms of people being able to receive and mail in their ballots. Isolated incidents of missing ballots or discarded envelopes have cropped up in recent weeks. But there’s no evidence that mail-in voting leads to fraudulent and rigged elections, which the Trump White House has repeatedly claimed.?
Voting by mail rarely results in fraud. States have put in place multiple policies and safeguards like bar codes and signature verification to combat risks and deter attempts to commit fraud. Comprehensive studies of billions of ballots cast over many years indicate that the rate of voter fraud is less than 0.0001%.
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database hereand learn more about mail-in voting here.
Link Copied!
Fact check: Claims that the White House pandemic team was disbanded
From CNN's Marshall Cohen?
Vice President Mike Pence and Kamala Harris briefly rehashed a dispute that has been a part of the political wrangling over Covid-19 —?whether or not?the Trump White House disbanded an Obama-era pandemic team.??
Harris?said?the Obama administration “created within the White House, an office that basically was responsible for monitoring pandemics” and claimed that the Trump administration “got rid of it.” Pence responded,?“Not true.”?
Facts First:?That the Trump administration got rid of the office is true, but it’s complicated. The White House pandemic team was disbanded under Trump, but some of the public health officials on the team were kept onboard and reassigned to related roles. It’s impossible to know if this move led to the bungled US response to Covid-19, but many leading public health experts have said the US was better off with the pandemic team intact.?
Two things are clear: Number one, the Obama administration created a specific team on the National Security Council to handle pandemic preparation and global health. Number two, that team no longer exists.?
The official who was in charge, Rear Adm. Timothy Ziemer, departed in 2018.?Around that time, John Bolton became Trump’s new national security adviser and reshuffled the NSC, which included changes to the pandemic team.?CNN previously reported?that?another?official with a similar purview has less authority than Ziemer had before he left.?
Regarding the fate of the?White House pandemic team, it depends?on?who you ask. Trump critics and former Obama administration officials say the team was fired, eliminated or disbanded. Trump and his conservative allies say the group was streamlined, reorganized or reassigned.?
Beth Cameron, who led the pandemic team after it was created by the Obama White House,?said?Trump “dissolved” the office and that this move significantly hampered the US response to Covid-19. Tim Morrison, who oversaw the new operation in the Trump administration,?said?the merged group of NSC officials was “stronger because related expertise could be commingled.”?
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here.
Link Copied!
Fact check: Harris' claim on Biden tax plan
From CNN's Katie Lobosco
Sen. Kamala Harris said that Joe Biden would not raise taxes on anyone earning less than $400,000 a year.?
Facts First:?This needs context and depends a lot on how you define taxes.?
At least two economic models show that Biden’s plan would not raise taxes on those earning less than $400,000 when considering direct income and payroll taxes. That includes analyses from the bipartisan?Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget?and the?Penn Wharton Budget Model.?
But the story is different when considering indirect taxes and the impact of other Biden proposals. Workers might bear some of the cost of his proposal to raise corporate taxes – resulting in lower after-tax wages. Another proposal from Biden to change 401(k)s could reduce the tax benefits of contributing to those accounts for some taxpayers.
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here.
Link Copied!
What did you think of tonight's debate?
From CNN's Melissa Mahtani
Vice President Mike Pence?and California Sen. Kamala Harris have just wrapped up their only debate of the 2020 election campaign and we want to hear from you.
Tell us what you thought of the debate and what impact it had on you using the form below.
Link Copied!
Both candidates sound notes of unity in closing remarks
From CNN's Josiah Ryan
In the final moments of tonight vice presidential debate, both candidates sought to sound a note of unity, even as they had spent the previous 90 minutes in vigorous disagreement.?
The candidates’ final remarks were given in response to a question from the debate’s moderator Susan Page, in which she read from an essay by an eighth grader about constant “arguing between Democrats and Republicans.”??
“If our leaders can’t get along, how are the citizens supposed to get along?” asked the eighth grader, according to Page.
Pence, who offered the first closing statement, cited the late Supreme Court Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Antonin Scalia, known for delivering opposing opinions from the bench while maintaining a close personal relationship.?
“Here in America, we can disagree, we can debate vigorously as Sen. Harris and I have on this stage tonight but when the debate is over we come together as Americans,” Pence added.?
Harris, for her part, cited the record of her running mate, Joe Biden, who built a reputation for working across the aisle during his decades serving in the US Senate.
Harris began by saying Biden had decided to run against Trump, after witnessing the racism, hatred and division on display in Charlottesville in 2017.
“One of the reasons Joe decided to run for president is after Charlottesville… It so troubled him and upset him like it did all of us, that there was that kind of hate and that division,” she said.
Link Copied!
Fly clings to Pence’s head in trending moment from debate
From CNN's Paul LeBlanc
Vice President Mike Pence listens to Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris during the vice presidential debate on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Patrick Semansky/AP
Vice President Mike Pence faced an unlikely challenger for the spotlight during Wednesday night’s debate when a common house fly landed on his head as he and Democratic opponent Sen. Kamala Harris sparred over their visions for America’s next four years.
The fly, which sat on Pence’s head for an impressive two minutes, drew a surge of tweets from debate viewers, including Democratic nominee Joe Biden, who tweeted a photo of himself with a fly swatter and the caption: “Pitch in $5 to help this campaign fly.” Later, within an hour of the debate ending, the Biden campaign started selling a “truth over flies” fly swatter.
The Democratic National Committee similarly leveraged the trending fly moment by tweeting the URL “Flywillvote.com,” which redirects to the DNC’s voter registration website.?
After the debate, CNN’s Jake Tapper quipped: “There were times during the debate that I thought the most effective being on that state to go after Vice President Pence was that fly that landed on his head.”
Link Copied!
Fact check: Pence's claim that Harris supported a ban on fracking
From CNN's Holmes Lybrand
US Vice President Mike Pence looks on during the vice presidential debate in Kingsbury Hall at the University of Utah on October 7, in Salt Lake City.
Eric Badarat/AFP/Getty Images
During tonight’s debate, Vice President Mike Pence?said?Kamala Harris?had?previously supported a ban on fracking.?
“You yourself said on multiple occasions when you were running for?president?that you would ban fracking,”?he?claimed.???
Facts First:?It’s true Harris voiced support for?a ban on?fracking during her primary run, starting with?public lands.??
During a CNN town hall in September 2019, Harris was?asked?if she would “commit to implementing a federal ban on fracking your first day in office.”??
“There’s no question I’m in favor of banning fracking,” Harris said. “So?yes. And starting with what we can do on day one around public lands. And then there has to be legislation.”??
The Biden campaign’s written?plan, however, proposes “banning new oil and gas permitting on public lands and waters,” and does not include a full ban?on?fracking.??
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here.
Link Copied!
Fact check: Pence on Trump and pre-existing conditions
From CNN's Tami Luhby
Vice President Mike Pence speaks during the vice presidential debate in Kingsbury Hall at the University of Utah on October 7 in Salt Lake City.
Eric Badarat/AFP/Getty Images
When asked about the future of American health care at the debate, Vice President Mike?Pence said, “President Trump and I have a plan to improve health care and to protect pre-existing conditions for every American.”?
Facts First:?This is false. The Trump administration, along with Republicans in Congress, have long promised?a plan to replace the Affordable Care Act and?that they would?also?protect people with pre-existing conditions. However, the President has yet to put forth a concrete plan that will provide the same strong provisions that currently exist under the ACA.?
In fact, the President is supporting a lawsuit brought by a coalition of Republican attorneys general that could topple the landmark health reform law and its provisions that ban insurers from denying coverage or charging higher premiums based on consumers’ pre-existing conditions.?The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments in the case on Nov. 10, a week after the election.?
In late September, Trump signed an executive order that stated that it’s US policy that people who suffer from pre-existing conditions will be protected. However, this is not actually a plan.?
Later in the debate, when asked directly to explain the administration’s health care plan, Pence switched topics.?
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here
Link Copied!
Fact check: Harris' claim that 1 in 5 businesses are closed
From CNN's Anneken Tappe
Democratic vice presidential nominee Kamala Harris gestures as she speaks during the vice presidential debate in Salt Lake City on Wednesday.
Robyn Beck/AFP/Getty Images
The pandemic has devastated the American economy. Sen. Kamala Harris said “1 in 5 businesses closed.”
Facts First:?This needs context. Harris is correct based on a June survey from the US Chamber of Commerce, but there’s little real-time data on small business closures and it’s hard to tell how many have permanently shuttered because of the pandemic.
The MetLife & US Chamber of Commerce Small Business Coronavirus Impact Poll from June found that 1 in 5 small businesses were closed, with 19% of them shuttered temporarily and only 1% closed permanently. Most businesses said then that they believe it will take some time to return to normal operations but that they will reopen.?
In July, the same poll found that 86% of small business reported that they were fully or partially open. At the same time, 58% of respondents to the survey worried that their businesses would have to permanently close due to the impact of the pandemic.
A Washington Post?analysis of a survey by researchers at Harvard, the University of Illinois and the University of Chicago said that 100,000 small businesses had permanently shut from March to May.
Link Copied!
Fact check: Harris' claim that Trump knew about coronavirus in January
From CNN's Jeremy Herb
Democratic vice presidential nominee Kamala Harris speaks during the vice presidential debate in Salt Lake City on Wednesday.
Justin Sullivan/Pool/Getty Images
Kamala Harris said during tonight’s debate that President?Trump knew about?the?threat?of?the?coronavirus?weeks before it took hold in?the?United States, noting that “on January 28th, the?vice?president?and the President were informed about the nature of this pandemic.”?
Facts First:?This is true. Trump told journalist Bob Woodward how deadly the virus was in a Feb. 7 interview, and Woodward reported that?the President?had been?briefed on the serious threat the virus posed on January 28.??
Woodward reported that Trump’s national security adviser, Robert O’Brien, told?the President?in a classified briefing that coronavirus would be the “biggest national security threat” of his presidency.?Trump’s head “popped up,” Woodward reported.?Pence told Fox News?he was also at the Jan. 28 national security?briefing.
Trump later told Woodward that he purposely downplayed the threat of the virus.?The President?said in a March 19 interview, “I wanted to always play it down.”?
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here
Link Copied!
Fact check: Will the US have a vaccine by the end of 2020?
From CNN's Jen Christensen
Vice President Mike Pence gave Americans hope that there would be a?coronavirus vaccine?by the end of the year.
“The reality is,?we will have a vaccine, we believe, before the end of this year, and it will have the capacity to save countless American lives and your continuous undermining of confidence in a vaccine is just unacceptable,” Pence said.?
Facts First:?This?needs context.
Though there are several vaccine candidates in different phases of testing, there is no guarantee that the US Food and Drug Administration will have approved a vaccine by the end of the year. And even once one is approved, it will likely still be many months before it’s widely available across the US.?
In?interviews?in September, the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, Dr. Anthony Fauci,?made it clear?that vaccine timeline projections are just that — projections — and it will take until next year?before vaccines?are widely distributed.?
“By the time you mobilize the distribution of the vaccinations, and you get the majority, or more, of the population vaccinated and protected, that’s likely not going to happen to the mid or end of 2021,” Fauci?told?MSNBC’s Andrea Mitchell.?
?For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here
Link Copied!
Here's the final speaking time tally for the VP debate
At the end of tonight’s debate, Vice President Mike Pence and Sen. Kamala Harris ended up with nearly the same amount of speaking time, differing by just a few seconds.
Link Copied!
Harris to Pence on systemic racism: "I will not be lectured"
From CNN's Jasmine Wright and Daniella Diaz
Kamala Harris proclaimed defiantly she will not “be lectured by the vice president” during a back-and-forth on criminal justice where she called the killing?of George Floyd “torture.”?
Vice President Mike Pence, responding to Harris’ assertion that there is systemic racism in this country and that Black people don’t feel as though they have the full rights in the system, said, “I must tell you this presumption that you hear consistently from Joe Biden and Kamala Harris, that America is systemically racist.”
Harris shot back at Pence, saying, “I will not sit here and be lectured by the vice president, on what it means to enforce the laws of our country. I’m the only one on this stage who has personally prosecuted everything from child sexual assault to homicide,” and went on to describe her record.?
Pence hit her back, parroting the arrest rate for Black men during her tenure as district attorney of San Francisco, along with other accusations.
Link Copied!
Was there justice for Breonna Taylor? Here's what Pence and Harris said
Vice President Mike Pence and Sen. Kamala Harris used the death of Breonna Taylor to discuss the issue of police violence plaguing the US.
Taylor was a 26-year-old Black emergency room technician and aspiring nurse in Louisville, Kentucky, who was killed by police on March 13.
Harris called Taylor “a beautiful young woman” whose life was taken “unjustifiably.”
She then vowed to immediately ban chokeholds if she and Joe Biden are elected.
“Bad cops are bad for good cops.?We need reform of policing in?America and our criminal justice?system. That’s why Joe and I will?immediately ban chokeholds and?carotid holds,” Harris said.
Pence said Taylor’s family had his “sympathies.” He also referenced the upswell of anti-police sentiment that has blanked the country following the deaths of Taylor and other Black Americans.
Pence dodges question on whether Trump will commit to a peaceful transfer of power
From CNN's Gregory Krieg
Vice President Mike Pence listens to Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris during the vice presidential debate in Salt Lake City on Wednesday.
Patrick Semansky/AP
President Trump has repeatedly refused to commit to a peaceful transfer of power if he loses the election.
Tonight, Vice President Mike Pence got the same question – and gave about the same answer, only in more measured tones.
First, Pence reiterated his confidence that the Republican ticket would be victorious on Election Day and talked up the “movement” behind Trump.
Then he pivoted to a rosy summation of Trump’s record and touted the President’s appointment of conservative judges to the federal bench.
Pence went on to accuse Democrats of trying to effectively steal the 2016 election from Trump, citing the investigation into Russian election interference – and parroting Trump’s familiar declaration that the probe found “no obstruction” and “no collusion.”
From there, it was onto impeachment, which Pence – again echoing Trump, though in a lower register – described as being centered on “a phone call.”
After a Hillary Clinton mention, Pence once again and finally used Trump’s equivocal phrasing, saying, “If we have a free and fair?election, we’ll have confidence?in it.?And I know and believe that?President Donald Trump will be?re-elected for four more years.”?
Karen Pence didn't wear a mask on stage after debate
From CNN's Betsy Klein
Vice President Mike Pence and wife Karen Pence appear on stage after the vice presidential debate against Democratic vice presidential nominee Sen. Kamala Harris a the University of Utah on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Alex Wong/Getty Images
Second lady Karen Pence appeared to break the agreed-upon rules on masks at the vice presidential debate Wednesday evening upon its conclusion.
In the aftermath of the first presidential debate, where some audience members, including the first lady and other Trump family members, removed their masks, the Commission on Presidential Debates mandated that everyone in the audience, with the only exceptions of the candidates and the moderator, wear a mask during future debates.
After the last questions were answers, Pence joined her husband, Vice President Mike Pence, on stage.
Douglas Emhoff joined his wife, Sen. Kamala Harris. Emhoff wore a mask as he stood by Harris. Karen Pence removed her mask.
Pence’s action was another example of the administration flouting its own guidelines on best public health practices and shirking the opportunity to lead on mask wearing.
Pence was present 11 days ago in the White House Rose Garden for an event nominating Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court. At least 12 attendees have since tested positive for Covid-19.
Fact check: Pence's claims about Biden and the Green New Deal
From CNN's Holmes Lybrand
Vice President Mike Pence Mike Pence gestures as he speaks during the vice presidential debate in Salt Lake City on Wednesday.
Robyn Beck/AFP/Getty Images
Vice President Mike Pence said during the debate that “while Joe Biden denied the Green New Deal… the Green New Deal is on their campaign website.”?
Facts First:?This is true but needs context. Biden’s campaign?website?does say the resolution is a “crucial framework” for addressing climate change, but his own plan differs from it in several ways. In particular, Biden’s plan does not include some of the Green New Deal’s proposed economic actions, such as guaranteeing a job for every American.
After lauding the “framework” of the Green New Deal, Biden’s campaign webpage on the environment lays out the bullet points of the candidate’s own plan to combat climate change, which includes items like building out energy-efficient infrastructure and setting a goal for the US to reach zero emissions by 2050.
While the two plans overlap on some environmental objectives, Biden’s plan does not include many of the social welfare proposals of the Green New Deal. For instance, he is not calling for a guaranteed job for each American with family and medical leave and paid vacations, as the deal proposes.
In other ways, the proposals differ less dramatically. Biden’s?plan?also has a goal of creating a carbon-pollution-free energy sector by 2035, whereas the Green New Deal proposed reaching 100% clean power in 10 years.
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here
Link Copied!
Harris embraces prosecutorial record and Pence faults her for it
From CNN's Dan Merica
Democratic vice presidential nominee and Senator from California, Kamala Harris gestures as she speaks during the vice presidential debate in Salt Lake City on Wednesday.
Robyn Beck/AFP/Getty Images
Sen. Kamala Harris, who was formerly the Attorney General of California and a top prosecutor in San Francisco, embraced her record as a prosecutor on Wednesday night, leading Vice President Mike Pence to quickly accuse her for not doing enough on criminal justice reform.
The fight highlights an issue that has faced the Trump campaign: Attacking Democratic nominee Joe Biden and Harris for being too soft on crime, while also faulting the former California senator for being too hard on crime during her time as a law enforcement official in the state.
Harris has struggled with her prosecutorial record ever since she launched her Democratic presidential campaign in 2019, both leaning on it and running away from it during her primary bid. But Harris’ answer on Wednesday night shows how the Biden campaign believes it could help their bid against Trump and Pence.
Pence hit back at Harris’ comment, noting some of the tough on crime efforts Harris oversaw when she was district attorney in San Francisco and attorney general of California.
“Your record speaks for itself,” Pence said. “President Trump and I have?fought for criminal justice?reform. … And we will do it for four more years.”
Link Copied!
Fact check: Pence's claim that the Biden campaign wants to "ban fracking"
From CNN's Holmes Lybrand
Vice President Mike Pence speaks during the vice presidential debate in Salt Lake City on Wednesday.
Justin Sullivan/Pool/Getty Images
Vice President Mike Pence claimed during tonight’s debate that the Biden campaign wants to “ban fracking.”?
Facts First:?This is misleading.?Joe Biden is not running on a proposal to completely ban fracking (hydraulic fracturing, a drilling method used to extract natural gas or oil). However, there is at least some basis for Pence’s claim: During the Democratic primary, Biden sometimes suggested he was proposing to get rid of all fracking. He’s also pledged to “establish an enforcement mechanism to achieve net-zero emissions no later than 2050,” which would almost certainly require a significant reduction in fracking.
Biden’s written?plan?never included a full ban on fracking; rather, it proposes “banning new oil and gas permitting on public lands and waters,” not ending all new fracking anywhere or ending all existing fracking on public lands and waters. Biden has explicitly?said?he does not support a nationwide fracking ban (though in part because he doesn’t believe such a ban would pass).
Biden created confusion about his stance with some of his comments during the Democratic primary. For example, he had this?exchange?with CNN’s Dana Bash during a July 2019 debate:
Without an act of Congress, the president could not issue an outright ban on fracking across the US. There are, however, a number of regulatory and executive actions an administration could take to prevent or shrink the use of fracking technology, particularly on federal land. However, most fracking takes place on private land, and any attempts to limit it would likely face legal challenges.
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here
Link Copied!
Fact check: Pence claims that the Obama administration "left the Strategic National Stockpile empty"
From CNN's Tara Subramaniam
Vice President Mike Pence claimed at tonight’s debate that the Obama?administration “left the?Strategic?National?Stockpile empty”?
Facts First:?This is?misleading.?
The Strategic National Stockpile was not empty before the coronavirus pandemic. For example, the stockpile contains enough?smallpox vaccines?for every American, among other medical resources.??
While Trump isn’t wrong to suggest he inherited a depleted stockpile of some medical supplies — the stockpile of masks, for example, was drained and not replenished by the Obama administration — it was not completely empty; he inherited significant quantities of other supplies.?Congress repeatedly did not pay for the stockpile to be replenished. And Trump had three years in office to build depleted stockpiles back up.?
A spokesperson for the Department of Health and Human Services also?confirmed?to CNN in late June that there had been about 19,000 ventilators in the national stockpile for “many years,” including 16,660 ventilators that were ready for immediate use in March 2020; the spokesperson confirmed that none of those 16,660 were purchased by the Trump administration.??
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here
Link Copied!
Pence says Americans "deserve a straight answer" on whether Biden would add Supreme Court seats
From CNN's Eric Bradner
California Sen. Kamala Harris ducked Vice President Mike Pence’s question about whether a Biden administration would seek to add seats to the Supreme Court if the Trump administration pushes through the nomination of Amy Coney Barrett to replace former Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
Harris did not answer directly, instead saying that the Senate should not move forward with Coney Barrett’s confirmation.
Pence shot back: “You gave a non-answer. Joe Biden gave a non-answer. The American people deserve a straight answer, and if you haven’t figured it out yet, the straight answer is, they are going to pack the Supreme Court.”
Biden, too, has avoided the question, including when Trump asked him last week in their first debate. The exchanges highlighted the difference between the Democratic ticket and some on the left of the party who have been invigorated by calls for sweeping change in the face of another Supreme Court pick by Trump. Both, however, have also been careful not to disavow the idea.
Pence and Harris spar over faith and the upcoming Supreme Court fight
From CNN's Dan Merica
Vice President Mike Pence listens as Democratic vice presidential nominee Kamala Harris speaks during the vice presidential debate on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Morry Gash/Pool/Getty Images
Mike Pence and Kamala Harris debated the upcoming fight over the nomination of Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court, sparring over how some of Barrett’s religious views could be central to that debate.
“We particularly hope we?don’t see the kind of attacks on?her Christian faith that we saw?before,” Pence said in response to the Supreme Court, noting that some members of the Senate have suggested they have questions about her association with a Christian group called People of Praise.
Pence then hit Harris for questioning another judicial nominee because the pick was a member of the Knights of Columbus, a Catholic group that is anti-abortion.
Harris hit back by casting the attack as personal.
Barrett’s religious beliefs came up during 2017 confirmation hearings to her current seat on the 7th US Circuit Court of Appeals.?California Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein questioned whether the nominee could separate her faith from her legal opinions.
At issue then, as it is now, is how her faith would inform her approach, especially on legal challenges to abortion rights.
About an hour into tonight’s debate, Vice President Mike Pence leads in speaking time with more than 28 minutes, maintaining about a 90 second lead ahead of Sen. Kamala Harris.
Link Copied!
Where things stand in the fight over Trump's Supreme Court pick
From CNN's Clare Foran and Ted Barrett?
Vice President Mike Pence and Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris listens to a question from moderator USA Today Washington Bureau Chief Susan Page during the vice presidential debate on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Justin Sullivan/Pool/AP
A major fight over the future of the Supreme Court is underway as Senate Republicans push to quickly confirm President Trump’s newest Supreme Court nominee, Amy Coney?Barrett, amid Democratic opposition.
Trump nominated?Barrett?following the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, setting off a high-stakes confirmation battle in the run-up to an election where control of the White House and Congress are on the line.?
Republicans, who control the Senate majority, signaled early on they would move as quickly as possible to take up the nomination, setting the stage for the possibility of a final confirmation vote before Election Day on Nov. 3.
The vetting process will kick into high gear next week when the Senate Judiciary Committee begins holding hearings on the nomination. During those hearings, which are scheduled to start on Monday, Oct. 12, lawmakers will have a chance to question the nominee ahead of a final vote on the Senate floor on confirmation.
Making matters more complicated, however, three Republican senators — Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, Mike Lee of Utah and Thom Tillis of North Carolina — recently tested positive for coronavirus?and are away from the Senate recovering.?
Lee and Tillis are on the Judiciary Committee and will be needed back in time to process and vote?Barrett?out of committee and Johnson’s vote will be needed on the floor to ensure enough Republicans are there to confirm her.
Republican Sens. Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska have already signaled they won’t back any GOP nominee ahead of Election Day. That leaves little room for Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell to find the votes if members of his conference contract or remain sick with Covid-19 since he can only?afford to lose?one more?Republican?besides Collins and Murkowski?and?still push through a nominee.
But confirming?Barrett?to the high court remains a top priority for Senate Republicans, who plan to press ahead and do whatever it takes to push for confirmation of the nominee as quickly as possible even in the face of the recent diagnoses within their ranks.
Johnson said on Monday that he will do everything he can to vote for?Barrett, even if he has to wear a “moon suit” to do it. And McConnell said on Monday that Republicans remain “full steam ahead with the fair, thorough, and timely confirmation process that Judge?Barrett, the court and the nation deserve.”?
Link Copied!
Fact check: Pence claims Trump "always" told the truth about coronavirus
From CNN's Marshall Cohen
Vice President Mike Pence claimed tonight that the Trump White House has “always” told the truth about Covid-19.??
“Let’s talk about respecting the American people. You respect the American people when you tell them the truth,” Harris said. Pence then interjected, “Which we’ve always done.”?
Facts First:?That’s?false. The Trump administration has not “always” been truthful about the pandemic.?
CNN’s fact-check reporter Daniel Dale?called this?“a whopper of a lie.” That’s because Trump has made?hundreds of false claims?during the pandemic, including false claims about his travel?restrictions, Covid-19 testing, the effectiveness of hydroxychloroquine, the national stockpile of ventilators, and more. In recent weeks, Trump even?lied about lying?about the virus.?
Trump has also admitted, in a?series of interviews?with Washington Post journalist Bob Woodward, that he concealed the true threat of the coronavirus from the American public earlier this year. Trump said, “I wanted to always play it down. I still like playing it down, because I don’t want to create a panic.”?
Link Copied!
Harris and Pence spar over trade wars
From CNN's Dan Merica
Democratic vice presidential nominee Sen. Kamala Harris and Vice President Mike Pence participate in the vice presidential debate moderated by Washington Bureau Chief for USA Today Susan Page in Salt Lake City on October 7.
Alex Wong/Getty Images
Sen. Kamala Harris excoriated Vice President Mike Pence and the Trump administration’s handling of trade tonight, leading the vice president to fire back at Joe Biden’s record on trade agreements.
Harris went on to note that farmers have experienced more bankruptcies in recent years and manufacturing jobs have dipped.
“Joe Biden has been a cheerleader?for communist China over the?last several decades.?And Sen. Harris, you’re?entitled to your opinion, not?your own facts,” Pence said.
Trump made renegotiating trade agreements a key priority during his first term, taking on the North American Free Trade Agreement and renegotiating it into what is now called the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement. The effort has been heralded by some trade unions and manufacturers, but farmers have complained about the way the trade war has damaged markets for products ranging from soybeans to cheese to pork.
Fact check: Pence claimed that Biden called Trump's travel restrictions on China "xenophobic"
From CNN's Holmes Lybrand
Vice President Mike Pence claimed that Joe Biden called President Trump’s travel restrictions on China “xenophobic.”?
“Biden opposed that decision. He said it was xenophobic,” Pence said.?
Facts First:?This needs context. It’s not clear Biden?even knew about Trump’s China travel restrictions when he called Trump xenophobic on the day the restrictions were unveiled; Biden has never explicitly linked his accusation of xenophobia to these travel restrictions.?
The campaign says Biden’s Jan. 31 accusations – that Trump has a record of “hysterical xenophobia” and “fear mongering” – were not about the travel restrictions at all. The campaign says Biden did not know about the restrictions at the time of his speech, since his campaign event in Iowa started shortly after the Trump administration briefing where the restrictions were revealed by Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar.??
Given the timing of Biden’s remarks, it’s not unreasonable for?Pence to infer that the former vice president was talking about the travel restrictions. But Biden never took an explicit position on the restrictions until his April declaration of support.?
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here
Link Copied!
Pence won't call climate crisis an "existential threat"
From CNN's Eric Bradner
Vice President Mike Pence speaks during the vice presidential debate in Salt Lake City on Wednesday.
Eric Baradat/AFP/Getty Images
Vice President Mike Pence did not agree with California Sen. Kamala Harris’ assessment that the climate crisis poses an existential threat, saying when he was asked directly about that assessment: “The climate is changing. We will follow the science.”
Pence, who has long denied climate science – including once writing in an op-ed that global warming is a “myth” — immediately pivoted to discussing tax policies, rather than talking in greater depth about the climate. He also criticized Democratic nominee Joe Biden and Harris for linking hurricanes and wildfires to climate change.
“There are no more hurricanes today than there were 100 years ago, but many climate alarmists use hurricanes and fires to try and sell the Green New Deal,” Pence said.
Harris, meanwhile, said Biden does not support the progressive Green New Deal but touted his proposed stimulus package, which would pump hundreds of billions of dollars into clean energy jobs.
“Let’s talk about who is prepared to lead our country over the course of the next four years on what is an existential threat to us as human beings. Joe is about saying, ‘We’re going to invest in renewable energy, it’s going to be about the creation of millions of jobs, we will achieve zero emissions by 2050, carbon neutral by 2035. Joe has a plan,” Harris said, adding that Biden would rejoin the Paris climate accord, which Trump left.
Link Copied!
Pence says Harris isn't entitled to her own facts
From CNN's Gregory Krieg
Vice President Mike Pence speaks during the vice presidential debate in Salt Lake City on Wednesday.
Justin Sullivan/Pool/Getty Images
The Trump administration’s relationship to the facts on any issue is generally tenuous, at best, and more often completely at odds with them.
And yet, on Wednesday night, Mike Pence challenged Kamala Harris over her accurate description of what would happen if the Affordable Care Act was struck down in court.
“Obamacare was a disaster,” Pence said, speaking in the past tense of a law that still exists.
He continued: “President Trump and I have a plan to improve health care and protect pre-existing conditions for every American.”
They have no such plan, despite Trump’s repeated promises to unveil one.
“Senator Harris,” Pence went on, “you’re entitled to your own opinion, but not your own facts.”
There he borrowed a line from the late former New York Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan – without attribution.
Fact check: Harris' claim that Trump said coronavirus was a hoax
From CNN's Holmes Lybrand
Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris speaks to Vice President Mike Pence during the vice presidential debate on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Julio Cortez/AP
“The President said it was a hoax,” Sen. Kamala Harris claimed in criticizing the administration’s downplaying of coronavirus.?
Harris is likely referring to Trump’s comments during a February rally, which the Biden campaign portrayed as Trump calling coronavirus a “hoax” in a September campaign ad.??
Facts?First:?This is misleading. Taken in totality, Trump’s comments at the Feb. 28 rally indicate that he is deriding Democrats for attacking his performance on coronavirus. A full 56 seconds pass between the two clips the campaign ad edited together.
In this section of his rally speech, Trump began by saying that “the Democrats are politicizing the coronavirus,” ridiculing Democrats for attacking his administration’s performance addressing the virus. The President then compared this attack to the investigation into Russian meddling in the 2016?election and?calling his impeachment a “hoax.”
Trump then said, “They’d been doing it since you got in. It’s all turning. They lost. It’s all turning. Think of it. Think of it. And this is their new hoax.”
The?next day?Trump was asked about this comment and tried to clarify what he said, claiming he was “referring to the action that [the Democrats] take to try and pin this on somebody, because we’ve done such a good job. The hoax is on them.”
That said, Trump’s clarification has not stopped some of his supporters from believing the pandemic is, in fact, a hoax. One Trump supporter attending a campaign rally in Michigan on Sept. 10 was asked by CNN’s Jim Acosta why he was not wearing a mask. “Because there’s no Covid,” he?said. “It’s a fake pandemic created to destroy the United States of America.”
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here
Link Copied!
Fact check: Pence's claim that Trump suspended all travel from China?
From CNN's Tara Subramaniam?
Vice President Mike Pence responds to a question during the vice presidential debate with Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Patrick Semansky/AP
Vice President Mike Pence claimed President Trump “suspended all travel from China” in response to the coronavirus pandemic.???
Facts First:?This is false. While Trump did restrict travel from?China, his policy was not an actual “ban”: It made exemptions for travel by US citizens, permanent residents, many of the family members of both groups and some others.???
The New York Times?reported in April?that nearly 40,000 people had flown to the US from China since the restrictions went into effect in early February.??
You can read more here about the travel restrictions Trump imposed on China?here.?
For more CNN fact checks, visit our fact check database here.
Link Copied!
Harris on Pence interruption: "Mr. Vice President, I am speaking"
From CNN's Dan Merica
Democratic vice presidential nominee Senator Kamala Harris speaks during the vice presidential campaign debate with?U.S. Vice President Mike Pence in Salt Lake City on Wednesday.
Brian Snyder/Reuters
Sen. Kamala Harris hit back at Vice President Mike Pence trying to interrupt one of her answers about coronavirus by bluntly saying: “Mr. Vice President, I am speaking.”
The moment came in the wake of a presidential debate last week where President Trump frequently interrupted Democratic nominee Joe Biden, leading to a chaotic and disorganized debate.
Moderator Susan Page has tried to stop that from happening by repeatedly telling each candidate they had time to answer “uninterrupted.”
But the debate has, at moments, veered into the two sparring for time.
“I have to weigh in,” Pence said, trying to stop Harris.
He was unable to, however, and Harris was able to deliver a message about the way coronavirus has impacted American lives.
When Page tried to cut off Harris again, the senator said, “He interrupted me, and I’d?like to just finish, please.”
The tone and tenor of the debate were front of mind for Harris’ team, who are well aware of the optics that could be at play given Harris is the first Black and South Asian woman to appear in a general election debate.
Here's how Biden's and Harris' positions on health care compare
From CNN's Gregory Krieg and Tami Luhby
Kamala Harris shifted over the course of her Democratic primary campaign from supporting “Medicare for All” to a more moderate plan.?
It called for a 10-year transition period — longer than the four years laid out in Bernie Sanders’ bill — though Americans could have bought into Medicare immediately if they wanted. Her proposal would not have raised middle class taxes, exempting households below $100,000, another distinction with Sanders. Harris would have placed new taxes on Wall Street transactions to help pay for it.
Notably, the Harris plan would have allowed a role for private insurers, a key wedge in the Democratic Party’s internal health care debate.
Biden, on the other hand, has been steady in his opposition to Medicare for All. Even as he gave way some on climate policy during the period after Sanders dropped out of the primary, the former vice president held steady on health care. At one point, Biden said he would veto the bill if it came to his desk, citing the cost.
The Biden plan would beef up Obamacare and add a public option, which his campaign has described as akin to Medicare.
On Covid-19 costs: Harris and Biden are also in lockstep, along with most rest of the party, on Covid-19 treatment costs, saying there shouldn’t be any. The same goes for an eventual vaccine.
Link Copied!
Harris zeroes in on Trump's taxes and mystery debt
From CNN's Gregory Krieg
Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris makes a point during the vice presidential debate with Vice President Mike Pence on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Julio Cortez/AP
The question: Do voters deserve a clearer picture of the presidential candidates’ health?
Kamala Harris’ answer: If you want to discuss transparency, let’s talk about Trump’s taxes.
If the presidential debate last week was a departure from historical norms, the vice presidential debate tonight is a return to them – neither candidate is engaging with tricky questions and both are turning to pre-planned talking points.
Harris, though, has a sharp one here. Calling on The New York Times’ reporting on Trump’s tax record, she zeroed in on the $400 million in debt he is believed to owe to unknown business partners or creditors.
Harris did return to Biden, though not his health, citing his openness about his finances – a stark contrast with Trump.
“Joe has been incredibly transparent, over many, many years. The one thing we all know about Joe, he puts it all out there. He is honest, he’s forthright,” she said. “But Donald Trump has been about covering up everything.”
Here's how Biden's and Harris' positions on climate change compare
From CNN's Gregory Krieg
Joe Biden and Kamala Harris were mostly aligned on climate questions, though the California senator – in part because of her office – offered more concrete support for the Green New Deal’s blueprint. She signed on to a resolution written by Massachusetts Sen. Ed Markey and New York Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez in 2019.?
When challenged by Trump in their debate last week, Biden said he opposed the Green New Deal. And while it’s true he hasn’t embraced it, his climate plan has been (cautiously) applauded by leading environmental groups.?
“Biden believes the Green New Deal is a crucial framework for meeting the climate challenges we face,” according to his campaign website, which touts his plan as a “Clean Energy Revolution.”
Both Harris and Biden support re-entering the Paris climate agreement, ending fossil fuel extraction on public land and putting a price on carbon emissions as part of broader policy visions.
But they differed somewhat, during the primary, on fracking.
Harris said she wanted to ban the practice, beginning on federal land.?
Biden has said he wants to limit it, but rejects a ban in favor of stopping new or additional fracking on federal land.?
“I am not banning fracking. Let me say that again: I am not banning fracking,” Biden said at a speech in Pittsburgh this summer. “No matter how many times Donald Trump lies about me.”
President Trump pledged in 2016 to repeal the Affordable Care Act, but that hasn’t happened. Now, his administration is backing court challenge that’s scheduled for Supreme Court just after the election in a case brought by a coalition of Republican state attorneys general and the Trump administration, who argue the law’s individual mandate is unconstitutional, and the?entire law must fall.
If the court wipes away Obamacare, it would have a sweeping impact on the nation’s health care system and on the lives of tens of millions of Americans — not only for the roughly 20 million people who’ve gained coverage on the Affordable Care Act exchanges and through the expansion of Medicaid to low-income adults.
The law is also what allows parents to keep their children on their health insurance plans until age 26 and obtain free mammograms, cholesterol checks and birth control.
And one of its most popular provisions is its strong protections for those with?pre-existing conditions, including barring insurers from denying coverage or charging higher premiums based on people’s health histories.
Harris and Pence both dodge question about Biden and Trump’s age?
From CNN's Kate Sullivan
Vice President Mike Pence speaks as Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris listens during the vice presidential debate on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Justin Sullivan/Pool/AP
Sen. Kamala Harris and Vice President Mike Pence both dodged a question at Wednesday’s debate about whether they had discussed “safeguards or?procedures” with Joe Biden or Donald Trump “when it comes to?presidential disability.”
Debate moderator Susan Page of USA Today noted, “One of you will make history on?January 20, you will be the vice president?to the oldest president the?United States has ever had.”
Page continued, “Donald Trump will be 74 years?old on Inauguration Day.?Joe Biden will be 78 years old.?That already has raised concerns?among some voters, concerns that?have been sharpened by President?Trump’s hospitalization in?recent days.?Vice President Pence, have you?had a conversation or reached an?agreement with President Trump?about safeguards or procedures?when it comes to presidential?disability??And if not, do you think you should?”
Pence did not answer the question, and instead pivoted to criticizing Harris for saying she would not trust Donald Trump’s word when it came to a vaccine. Harris said during the debate she would trust the scientists and public health experts when it comes to a potential vaccine, but not solely Trump.?
When the question was posed to her, Harris did not answer the question, either. She instead spoke about her record and the barriers she has broken throughout her career — the first woman of color and Black woman to be elected Attorney General of California, the second Black woman to be elected to the US Senate, and now the first Black and South Asian woman to be a major party vice presidential nominee.?
Coronavirus' impact on the economy has been a key topic of tonight's debate. Here's where stimulus talks stand.
From CNN's Katie Lobosco
Millions of Americans are still?out of work. Many?small businesses?and?major airlines?are struggling to stay afloat. And states are still contending with massive budget gaps.
But those in need of relief from the coronavirus pandemic won’t see more money from the federal government anytime soon. After lawmakers struggled for months to agree on an another economic stimulus package, President Donald Trump this week ordered his negotiators to halt talks until after the election.
Democrats and Republicans never got very close to a deal,?but there was bipartisan support?for a second round of stimulus checks, extending a boost to unemployment benefits, providing more support for small businesses and more money for schools.
We’re tracking approximate speaking times for the candidates during tonight’s debate. In the first 30 minutes, Vice President Mike Pence has talked more than 13.5 minutes, leading Sen. Harris by almost a minute and a half.
CORRECTION: An earlier version of this post incorrectly switched the speaking times.
Link Copied!
Pence tells Harris to "stop playing politics" with lives
Analysis from CNN's Kevin Liptak
Vice President Mike Pence speaks during the vice presidential debate with Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Julio Cortez/AP
“Stop playing politics with people’s lives” is a phrase you would probably expect during a debate this year — just not coming from someone working for President Trump.
Nevertheless, Vice President Mike Pence made the accusation, saying Sen. Kamala Harris was undermining confidence in an eventual coronavirus vaccine by saying she wouldn’t take it unless it was endorsed by public health experts.
His attack seemed to ignore the repeated efforts by Trump to explicitly insert politics into the pandemic, including efforts to develop a vaccine.
Just hours earlier, Trump made explicit acknowledgment that vaccine development was being influenced by politics, bemoaning rules that make it unlikely a vaccine will be approved by Election Day. And CNN reported on Tuesday that Trump has phoned vaccine makers to press them to work quicker on a vaccine — preferably before Nov. 3.
Link Copied!
Pence defends packed Rose Garden event: Trump administration trusts Americans
From CNN's Betsy Klein:
Vice President Mike Pence speaks during the vice presidential debate on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Eric Baradat/AFP/Getty Images
Vice President Mike Pence defended the administration’s decision to hold a packed event in the White House Rose Garden 11 days ago amid a global pandemic, days before the President, first lady, and multiple attendees tested positive for Covid-19.?
Pence framed his response through the lens of personal freedom as he answered a question from vice presidential debate moderator Susan Page about the event, that, Page suggested, “seems to have been a super spreader event,” and how the administration could expect Americans to follow safety guidelines when they did not follow them themselves.
Pence further defended the decision to hold the event.?
“The reality is, the work of the President of the United States goes on. A vacancy in the Supreme Court of the United States has come upon us and the president introduced Judge Amy Coney Barrett,” he said.?
He dismissed questions that the event could have been a “super spreader” as “a great deal of speculation, and noted that “many,” though not all, people at the event “actually were tested for coronavirus.”
He also highlighted that the event was outside, “Which all of our scientists regularly routinely advise.” However, before guests headed to the Rose Garden, some attended gatherings inside the White House reception rooms where social distancing was not practiced — including with hugs and handshakes.
“The difference here is President Trump and I trust the American people to make choices in the best interest of their health,” he said, pivoting to criticize Democratic nominee Joe Biden and vice presidential candidate for “consistently” talking about mandates.
But the proposal isn’t a simple fix for what ails the US. It would equal taking American society back to the drawing board and rebuilding it from the safety net up.
What was entered as official legislative language on Capitol Hill declares the government should take a stronger position on everything from cutting carbon emissions to giving every American a job to working with family farmers to retrofitting every building in the country.
Harris on a vaccine: "If Donald Trump tells us to?take it, I'm not taking it"
From CNN's Dan Merica
Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris, D-Calif., answers a question as Vice President Mike Pence listens during the vice presidential debate on Wed
Morry Gash/Pool/AP
Kamala Harris directly said on Wednesday that if there is a coronavirus vaccine available during Donald Trump’s administration that is not embraced by scientific advisers but pushed by the President, she will not take it.
But if the scientific advisers like Dr. Anthony Fauci back the vaccine, she would.
The Trump campaign has slammed Harris during the campaign for questioning a vaccine approved by Trump.
Harris, echoing her answer tonight, told CNN earlier this year that she would not outright trust a vaccine unless it came from a “credible” source.
Vice President Mike Pence jumped on those past comments tonight.
“Your continuous undermining of?confidence in a vaccine is?unacceptable,” Pence said.
Americans have sacrificed too much due to the "incompetence of?this administration," Harris says
Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris responds to a question during the vice presidential debate on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Julio Cortez/AP
Sen. Kamala Harris, the Democratic nominee for vice president, took umbrage with how President Trump and his administration responded to the coronavirus pandemic, saying people needed information they may “not want people?to hear, but they need to hear?so they can protect themselves.”
Pence knocks Biden for plagiarism, the issue that ended his 1988 campaign
From CNN's Kevin Liptak
Vice President Mike Pence responds during the vice presidential debate on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Julio Cortez/AP
Vice President Mike Pence took his first crack at Joe Biden minutes into the debate, making an allusion to the decades-old episode which ended Biden’s first presidential bid.
Describing the Biden-Harris plan to combat coronavirus, Pence suggested it was ripped from the current Trump administration approach.
Biden withdrew from the 1988 presidential race after acknowledging he lifted phrases from a British politician without attribution.?Pence’s line was an early cut that signaled his willingness to make personal attacks, even amid answers about policy and governing.
Harris: Trump's handling of Covid "the greatest?failure of any presidential?administration"
From CNN's Dan Merica
Kamala Harris arrives on stage for the vice presidential debate on Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Robyn Beck/AFP/Getty Images
Kamala Harris opened the presidential debate by honing in on Mike Pence and the Trump administration’s greatest vulnerability: The handling of the coronavirus.
“The American people have?witnessed what is the greatest?failure of any presidential?administration in the history of?our country,” Harris said at the outset of the debate before attacking the Trump administration for obscuring the facts around the virus.
Harris added: “They minimized the seriousness?of it.”
Coronavirus will likely be the most important issue at the debate, both because of the way it has reshaped American life and the fact that Trump is still in the White House recovering from the disease.
Harris said that the Biden administration would focus on “contact tracing, testing,?administration of the vaccine,?and making sure that it will be?free for all.”
“That is the plan that Joe Biden?has and that I have, knowing?that we have to get ahold of?what has been going on,” Harris concluded.
Moderator USA Today Washington Bureau Chief Susan Page takes her seat for the vice presidential debate between Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris and Vice President Mike Pence at the University of Utah Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Justin Sullivan/Pool/AP
Moderator Susan Page began the debate by beseeching Mike Pence and Kamala Harris to mind their manners – a none-too-subtle nod to President Trump’s behavior at least week’s debate with Joe Biden.
“You will have two minutes to?answer without interruption by?me, or the other candidate,” Page said.
And so they did. Pence started off his first answer by saying what an honor it was to share the stage with Harris.
After a debate many observers described as the nastiest in modern history, there’s nowhere to go but up.
The candidates are talking about Covid-19 now. Here are the facts you should know
From CNN's Amanda Watts and Ben Tinker
The coronavirus pandemic and its impact on the population and economy has become a key issue of the 2020 election and continues to shape the campaign.
Here are key facts you need to know:
US deaths: More than?211,000?people have died from coronavirus in the US.
US cases: The US leads the world in total confirmed coronavirus cases with over 7.5 million infections, according to Johns Hopkins University data. India, Brazil and Russia follow behind.
Daily infections: In a sign that?cases are?trending up across the United States, for the first time since Aug. 21, the?nation?is seeing and average of?over 44,000 new?Covid-19 cases per day, according to Johns Hopkins University?data.? Currently, the nation averages?44,190 new cases?per day, that is?up 7%?from last week.???
Vaccine development: There are currently 10 Covid-19?vaccine?candidates in late-stage, large clinical trials around the world as of Oct. 6, according to the World Health Organization.
Vaccine timeline: A?vaccine?could be available in limited doses as soon as November or December, Dr. Anthony Fauci, the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, predicted earlier this week. The US Food and Drug Administration made clear Tuesday it will want to see two months of follow-up data after volunteers get their second dose of?vaccine?as part of clinical trials testing potential coronavirus?vaccines. That would make it difficult, if not impossible, for any?vaccine?maker to apply for emergency use authorization by Election Day, as President Trump has tried to promise, or by the end of October, as the CEO of Pfizer has hinted.
Here’s where new cases are rising across the US in comparison to the previous week:
Link Copied!
Trump hasn't let Pence have his moment this week
From CNN's Kevin Liptak
Vice President Mike Pence knows his place. Perhaps more than any other vice president in recent memory, his defining political characteristic is the unyielding fealty to the President that leaves little question who is in charge.
But if he was wondering this week about his station — perhaps because his boss was hospitalized with coronavirus, receiving supplemental oxygen and being administrated an unprecedented cocktail of drugs — he was reminded today that Trump remains the big man at the White House.
Hours before he was due to emerge onstage in Salt Lake City, Trump made his first appearance since returning home from the hospital, an upbeat if strained direct-to-camera video declaring his illness a “blessing from God.”
All week, the focus has been on the President’s illness. Trump grew irritated when discussion of presidential succession arose in the news, upset that anyone would think he might transfer power to Pence.
If tonight was Pence’s opportunity to shine, Trump ensured he was still the one in the spotlight. And if past is precedent, he will continue making that known during the debate. In 2016, he live-tweeted Pence’s face-off with Sen. Tim Kaine.
Link Copied!
The debate has begun
Democratic vice presidential nominee Sen. Kamala Harris and U.S. Vice President Mike Pence participate in the vice presidential debate at the University of Utah on October 7, in Salt Lake City, Utah.?
Alex Wong/Getty Images
Vice President Mike Pence and California Sen. Kamala Harris’ only vice presidential debate has kicked off. It will run for 90 minutes with no commercial breaks.
Harris?made history?as she walked on the stage, becoming the first Black and South Asian woman to participate in a general?election debate.
Tonight’s debate comes as the Trump administration reels from an outbreak of Covid-19 at the White House and erratic decisions by the commander in chief.
How this presidential election is already much different from 2016
CNN’s John King dove into the data tonight to explain how the upcoming presidential election “is not 2016” when President Trump defeated Hillary Clinton.
Undecided voters weigh in on what they are looking for in tonight's debate
From CNN's Josiah Ryan
Ahead of tonight’s vice presidential debate, a panel of undecided voters spoke with CNN’s Sara Sidner about what they are looking for as Sen. Kamala Harris and Vice President Mike Pence prepare to face off.?
Another undecided voter, Morgan, said it was very important to her that Harris is the first woman of color on a major American political party’s ticket, saying, “it should be important to everybody.”?
“Representation matters,” she said. “Its not the only thing but it’s definitely a big thing. “…I think we should all be paying attention to that.”
Sam, also on the panel, chimed in saying he agreed with Morgan,
“We haven’t had a ton of diversity in the office ever, so I think it’s great,” he told Sidner.?
Link Copied!
Pence's role as head of coronavirus task force in the spotlight at tonight's debate
From CNN's Kevin Liptak
Vice President Mike Pence speaks during a White House Coronavirus Task Force press briefing at the U.S. Department of Education July 8, in Washington.
Alex Wong/Getty Images
Coronavirus was already going to be the overriding theme of tonight’s debate; the virus is ripping through the West Wing and the candidates will be speaking to each other through plexiglass.?
But for Vice President Mike Pence, the pandemic has also provided the highest-profile platform of his tenure. He was appointed in late February to lead the White House coronavirus task force, the often-at-odds panel of administration officials designated with leading the federal response.
By almost all accounts, that response has been mismanaged; the United States leads the world in cases, early missteps led to shortages in supplies and Americans widely disapprove of how the Trump administration has handled the pandemic.
Much of the blame has fallen on Trump himself, who has alternated during the crisis from wanting to act as the administration’s front man to shoving responsibility elsewhere, namely on Pence. In May, Trump actually planned to disband Pence’s task force before reversing himself, saying he didn’t realize how popular it was.
Among governors and public health officials, Pence has actually received relatively high marks for communication and responsiveness, even if overall the administration’s efforts have been halting. But that’s not likely something Pence will tout tonight; he has studiously placed all credit for the response on Trump.
Link Copied!
These are the safety measures being taken at tonight's debate?
From CNN's Ryan Nobles, Kyung Lah, Linh Tran and DJ Judd
Audience members enter Kingsbury Hall for the vice presidential debate between Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Kamala Harris, D-Calif., and Vice President Mike Pence on Wednesday at University of Utah in Salt Lake City.
Patrick Semansky/AP
The audience from the debate has just started to trickle in to the venue, Kingsbury Hall, on the campus of the University of Utah.
Inside, spectators will be seated in two different sections.?
There is a small group of chairs set up on the floor of the debate hall for the VIP guests directly in front of the stage. Those chairs are distanced from each other.
In the balcony, the general audience is being seated by student ushers wearing rubber black gloves and the standard surgical-style masks that everyone in the debate hall is required to wear.
The seats are assigned and are strategically socially distanced. Each attendee is holding a sizable placard that serves as their ticket that also tells them where they will be seated. Certain attendees are seated together but the groups of clustered attendees are separated.
The front two rows over the balcony have signs that say “Thank you for leaving this seat empty” in observance of social distancing.
More precautions: Each attendee had their temperature checked before entering the building. There are also hand sanitizing stations as you enter. All attendees were also required to receive a negative result on a Covid-19 test 72 hours before today’s event.
Staff was also seen wiping down the desks and chairs where California Sen. Kamala Harris, Vice President Mike Pence, and moderator Susan Page are expected to sit during tonight’s debate.
CNN's Chris Cillizza answers your questions live about tonight's debate
Vice President Mike Pence and Democratic nominee Sen. Kamala Harris are set to face off in the only vice presidential debate of the 2020 election starting at 9 p.m. ET on CNN.
CNN’s Chris Cillizza is answering viewers’ questions ahead of tonight’s debate.
Watch live:
Link Copied!
Aides expect Pence to stay on message tonight
From CNN's Ryan Nobles
While Vice President Mike Pence will be prepared to defend the administration’s response to the coronavirus pandemic, he won’t be content to stay on defense.
Pence is ready to flip the conversation from the administration’s response to the virus to Harris’ prior support for Medicare For All. It will be part of broader attempt to tie the Biden/Harris ticket to the far left elements of the Democratic party.
Pence is known for his message discipline and his aides expect “on message Mike,” as he is known in the campaign, to be on full display tonight.?
Link Copied!
Harris will "talk to people at home," Biden aide says
From CNN's Kyung Lah
California Sen. Kamala Harris is not on stage to “eviscerate Mike Pence,” said Joe Biden aide Symone Sanders.
“She is there to really talk to people at home and what they’re feeling,” Sanders added.
Harris will speak to the pain of Americans, drawing a stark contrast with what the public has heard from President Trump. This is a tactic that Harris is practiced in from her time on the Democratic presidential campaign trail, where her stump speech often distilled economic policy into simple ways that connected with supporters — how buying tires for the family car meant a working class family’s entire savings.
This is where gender becomes her advantage — using a softer approach to directly speak to the pain of Americans.
Gender and race optics are both issues the campaign is mindful of, even as Harris makes history tonight. (Harris will make history as the first Black and South Asian woman to participate in a general election debate.) But these are challenges, multiple aides say, that are not new or uncomfortable for Harris.
The Commission on Presidential Debates said it was taking additional health and safety precautions at the debate,?including using plexiglass, in the wake of President Trump’s positive diagnosis.
Here are some key measures:
Space on stage: Pence and Harris will be seated for the debate, and the distance between the center of the chairs will be 12 feet and 3 inches, according to the commission. The moderator will also be seated and will be at a similar distance of 12 feet and 3 inches from the candidates.
Plexiglass: It will be used at the debate, and there will not be a handshake or physical contact between the candidates or with the moderator.
Testing: Harris and Pence will be tested for coronavirus before the debate. Once on stage, neither the candidates nor the moderator will wear masks.
Audience: There will be a small number of ticketed guests, according to the CPD. Everyone in the debate hall will be subject to a variety of health and safety protocols, according to the commission, including coronavirus testing and wearing masks.
Here’s what the debate stage looks like:
Members of the production crew stand in on the stage near plexiglass barriers which will serve as a way to protect the spread of Covid-19 as preparations take place for the vice presidential debate at the University of Utah, on Tuesday in Salt Lake City.
Patrick Semansky/AP
A member of the production staff puts labels on seats in an effort to keep seats socially distanced ahead of the vice presidential debate at the University of Utah, On Wednesday in Salt Lake City.
Julio Cortez/AP
Plexiglass protections between the debaters are seen on the stage of the debate hall ahead of the vice presidential debate in Kingsbury Hall of the University of Utah October 6, in Salt Lake City.
Eric Baradat/AFP/Getty Images
The stage is set ahead of the vice presidential debate in Kingsbury Hall of the University of Utah October 7, in Salt Lake City.
Eric Baradat/AFP/Getty Images
Link Copied!
5 million votes have been cast in 2020 election so far
From CNN's Adam Levy, Ethan Cohen and Liz Stark
Working in bipartisan pairs, canvassers process mail-in ballots in a warehouse at the Anne Arundel County Board of Elections headquarters on October 7, in Glen Burnie, Maryland.
Drew Angerer/Getty Images
As Vice President?Mike Pence and California Sen. Kamala Harris meet in Salt Lake City tonight for their first and only vice presidential debate, more than 5.4 million Americans have already voted in the general election, according to a CNN and Edison Research survey of election officials in 31 states reporting voting data.
Nationally, Democrats are voting in droves ahead of the election, making up more than half the ballots cast so far in states with party data available, and Republicans making up about one-quarter of the votes so far.
That detailed information, analyzed by Catalist, a company that provides data, analytics and other services to Democrats, academics and nonprofit issue-advocacy organizations, is giving new insights into who is voting before November. Catalist analyzed almost 4.5 million ballots cast in 27 states so far.
This data does not predict the outcome of any race, as polling shows Republicans strongly prefer voting in person on Election Day rather than early. The information contains insights and details about who is voting ahead of Nov. 3. While the returns represent a small fraction of the expected number of ballots to be cast in 2020 — Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton received about 130 million votes combined four years ago — some states have reported that the numbers of ballot requests and returns have already set records.
Despite the surge in preelection voting this year, the gender breakdown remains similar to this point in 2016: 55% of the ballots cast so far are from women and 45% are from men. Among CNN’s key states, Wisconsin, at 57%, has the largest share of ballots returned by women.
Most of CNN’s key states are seeing gender breakdowns among ballots cast similar to those of this point four years ago, but there are exceptions. At this point in 2016, roughly 61% of Georgia’s ballots cast had come from women, but so far this year, it’s only 56%.
Biden crosses 270 threshold in CNN's electoral college outlook for first time
From CNN's David Chalian and Terence Burlij
Joe Biden is surging in the battle for the White House with less than four weeks to go until Election Day.
In our latest Electoral College outlook, the Democratic presidential nominee crosses the 270 threshold for the first time this year. If you add up the states that are currently rated as solidly in his camp (203 electoral votes) and those leaning in his direction (87 electoral votes), it brings his total to 290 electoral votes.
As President Trump remains infected with coronavirus and absent from the campaign trail, his campaign finds itself in its worst political position since the start of the campaign season. The President had a disastrous debate performance last week in what was one of his last best chances to turn things around before millions of Americans began casting their ballots.
It only got worse from there, when his response to contracting Covid-19 was to tell the country not to worry about it and demonstrate a brazen lack of leadership by removing his mask on a White House balcony overlooking the South Lawn for all the world to see —precisely the move that nearly every scientist and expert says goes against promoting the best weapon we currently have to combat the virus.
The Trump campaign also finds itself at a significant competitive disadvantage with the Biden campaign when it comes to money to spend on critical TV ads in the homestretch — exactly the moment when a campaign wants to maximize spending to open as many paths to 270 as possible.
Meanwhile, the former vice president appears to have built back up that so-called blue wall across the Midwest that Trump busted through in 2016 to secure his victory.
Since our last Electoral College outlook, there have been no fewer than eight polls that meet CNN’s reporting standards out of Pennsylvania — a critical battleground state for either candidate’s path to 270 electoral votes. Biden never held less than a 5-percentage point lead in any of them and his support level was never below 49%. We are moving Pennsylvania back to Leans Democratic.
From CNN's Eric Bradner,?Gregory Krieg?and?Dan Merica
Kamala Harris listens as Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden speaks following a coronavirus briefing with health experts at the Hotel DuPont on August 13, in Wilmington, Delaware.?
Drew Angerer/Getty Images
California Sen.?Kamala Harris?entered the Democratic presidential primary as a supporter of “Medicare for All,” the national health insurance plan written and championed by her competitor Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders.
By the time she dropped out, in December 2019, the senator from California had rowed?back her support and unveiled her own plan,?which called for transitioning to a government-run program over 10 years but allowing private insurers to participate.
Now she is making the case for Biden and his proposal to beef up the Affordable Care Act and create a public option on top of it.
President Trump and Vice President Mike Pence don’t have a credible health care plan of their own, but that won’t stop the vice president from trying to paint Harris as a tool of the “radical left” over both her initial backing of Medicare for All and her own proposal.
Her ability to pivot out of that conversation and into one about the current administration’s policies, both on the pandemic and their support for a lawsuit that threatens the ACA, could be a defining moment.??
Link Copied!
CDC director says it is safe for Pence to participate in tonight's debate
From CNN's Lauren Mascarenhas
Ahead of tonight’s debate, US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Director Dr. Robert Redfield said in a statement that it is safe for Vice President Mike Pence to participate in the vice presidential debate.
Redfield said the CDC had a consultation with?Dr. Jesse?Schonau, currently serving in the White House medical unit, and based on the descriptions, “the Vice President is?not?a close contact of any known person with Covid-19, including the President.”
For Covid-19, the CDC defines a close contact as a person who was within six feet of?an?infected person for?15?minutes or more, starting from two days before illness onset or positive specimen collection, until the patient is isolated.
Link Copied!
How Harris and Pence have been preparing for tonight's debate
From CNN's Eric Bradner,?Gregory Krieg?and?Dan Merica
Four years ago, then-Indiana Gov.?Mike Pence?let out an exasperated “there you go again” on the debate stage after his opponent, Virginia Sen.?Tim Kaine, said “America, you need a ‘You’re hired’ president, not a ‘You’re fired’ president.”
It was actually the first time Kaine, then the Democratic vice presidential nominee, uttered the phrase during the debate, but Pence didn’t realize that. He had repeatedly heard the line ahead of time from the man playing the role of Kaine in his debate prep, former GOP Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker.
It’s that kind of preparation that helped him deliver a strong debate performance in 2016, and a source familiar with Pence’s debate prep this time around says he is approaching it the same way — with traditional, tried and true methods like mock debates that last 90 minutes without a break, just like the real thing.
Only a small group of advisers are in the room helping him, including former Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi, who has played the role of Kamala Harris, along with others.
Walker predicts that Harris will be a tougher opponent than Kaine was four years ago.
With President Trump, first lady Melania Trump, and more than a dozen White House staffers now sick with Covid-19, Pence aides are bracing for Harris to turn the conversation to the pandemic as much as possible. And, of course, the vice president is the head of the White House coronavirus task force.
Harris sources say don’t expect her to pull her punches just because the President contracted coronavirus, especially since he is no longer in the hospital.
Harris, like Pence, is preparing in a conventional way. Former South Bend, Indiana, Mayor Pete Buttigieg, Pence’s fellow Hoosier, plays the role of the vice president in her mock debates, according a source familiar with her prep.
Lily Adams, Harris’ former communications director both in the Senate and during her presidential campaign, said the California senator is a studier, a voracious reader of briefing books, and taking in the advice of her staff.
In her prep, Adams said Harris is very focused on finding ways to make her positions relatable.
“Let’s really dig deep on how does that impact an actual person’s life? Let me explain the problem that way, as opposed to using some sort of set term or a term that only makes sense in Washington, DC,” Adams recalls Harris asking in prep in the past with staff.
The parents of Kayla Mueller will be Pence's guests tonight
From CNN's Daniella Diaz
In this screenshot from the RNC’s livestream of the 2020 Republican National Convention, Carl and Marsha Mueller, parents of humanitarian worker Kayla Mueller who was killed by ISIS, address the virtual convention on August 27.
Courtesy of the Committee on Arrangements for the 2020 Republican National Committee via Getty Images
Vice President Mike?Pence’s guest at tonight’s debate will be the parents of Kayla Mueller, who was kidnapped and killed by ISIS.
In 2012, Kayla?traveled?to the Turkey/Syria border to work with the Danish Refugee Council and the humanitarian organization Support to Life, which assisted families forced to flee their homes.
She was taken hostage by ISIS in Aleppo, Syria, in 2013 after she visited a Spanish MSF (Doctors Without Borders) hospital. The family?confirmed?Kayla’s death in 2015.
Link Copied!
Ahead of tonight's debate, Salt Lake City mayor called on city to reimpose tougher restrictions
From CNN's Steve Almasy and Christina Maxouris
Salt Lake City Mayor Erin Mendenhall speaks during a news conference Monday, Sept. 21, in Salt Lake City.
Rick Bowmer/AP
Almost nine months into the coronavirus pandemic, the crisis shows no signs of abating, even in states that were once not considered Covid-19 hotspots.
Utah, where the vice presidential candidates will debate tonight, is averaging more than 1,000 new cases each day for the past week. That’s the highest it’s been since the first cases in the US were reported in late January.
Salt Lake City Mayor Erin Mendenhall on Tuesday requested the city reimpose tougher restrictions like smaller limits on social gatherings.
The head of the Oregon Health Authority on Tuesday said the state is seeing a significant spike in new coronavirus cases since autumn began.
“We have reversed the progress we made in the late summer, and our most recent modeling shows the virus is spreading more rapidly,” Pat Allen told reporters.
State officials in Alaska are seeing record numbers of cases and its highest ever test positivity rate (4.19%).
In Montana, health officials reported more than 500 new cases for the first time. According to The Covid Tracking Project, the state on Monday reported 201 new hospitalizations, a record.
Overall cases across the nation are on the rise. More than 50,000 daily cases were reported on Friday and Saturday. The last time the US saw more than 50,000 cases back to back was mid-August.
Just four states — Hawaii, Kansas, Missouri and South Carolina — are reporting a decline in coronavirus cases over the past week, according to data from Johns Hopkins University.
Link Copied!
What we know about Harris' debate strategy
From CNN's Dan Merica,?Kyung Lah,?MJ Lee?and?Jasmine Wright
California Senator Kamala Harris speaks onstage during the fourth Democratic primary debate of the 2020 presidential campaign season co-hosted by The New York Times and CNN at Otterbein University in Westerville, Ohio on October 15, 2019.
Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images
Kamala Harris?and?Mike Pence?will be the two candidates?on the debate stage?in Utah tonight, but the California senator’s goal is to make the contest all about the man who isn’t there: President?Trump.
Harris, according to multiple Democrats familiar with her debate strategy, is preparing for the highest profile moment in her political career by studying both Trump and Pence’s past positions, speaking with people who either know Pence well or have debated him in the past and preparing for a vice president who, unlike his boss, doesn’t show much emotion on the debate stage.
But the goal, the sources said, is to make the debate about more than Pence and focus the conversation on Trump’s mishandling of coronavirus, much like Biden tried to do a week earlier.
“Even though it is a vice presidential debate, the debate is about Donald Trump and Joe Biden,” said a Biden campaign aide. “And it is all about making the case for why we need Joe Biden in this moment and why Donald Trump has failed.”
Harris will make history as the first Black and South Asian woman to participate in a general election debate.
Pence's?debate style is expected to be much different than Trump's
From CNN's Ryan Nobles
More than a week ago Americans saw a combative Donald Trump aggressively attack Joe Biden, cut him off and spend the entire debate in a confrontational posture. Mike?Pence?will be much different.
Expect?Pence?to abide by the rules, speak in an even handed manner and find ways to make his points with a measured tone.
Aides say he will still “prosecute” the case against Kamala Harris and won’t be afraid to return fire when given the opportunity. The difference will be he will do so with a smile.
Link Copied!
Biden campaign highlights historic nature of Harris' nomination in new ads?
From CNN's Jasmine Wright
Joe Biden’s presidential campaign on Tuesday released a set of nationwide ads featuring only California Sen. Kamala Harris, the Democratic ticket’s vice-presidential candidate, ahead of her face off with Vice President Mike Pence at the debate in Salt Lake City.
It’s her second solo rollout of nationwide paid ads on the Biden-Harris campaign, and will air on television, radio and digital and highlights the historic nature of her nomination as the first Black and South Asian woman on a major party’s presidential ticket
The ads, viewed first by CNN, are aimed at engaging Black voters — particularly in battleground states — in an effort to elevate participation in the campaign. And they’re part of the ticket’s weekly seven-figure investment in outreach in battleground states in an effort to provide additional “information and messaging” around the vice presidential debate about Harris’ candidacy, according to a campaign aide.
The ads will be released nationwide with an emphasis on Pennsylvania, Ohio, Michigan and Georgia, among other states, the aide said.
One 30-second spot,?called “Mirrors,” is a nod to the barrier breaking nature of Harris’ nomination as the first Black and South Asian woman on a major party’s presidential ticket. It shows an elementary school aged Black girl watching footage of Harris’ selection on her couch with a female narrator calling it a “historic decision.”
The small girl reacts in complete awe and then the video shows her on stage, with the message “On November 3rd, vote for her” in bold white letters appearing over her.
“Our time is now,” the young girl declares.
It’s akin to a message both Harris and Biden have sought to magnify — the positive impact that the representation of the nation’s first Black and South Asian woman on a major party’s presidential ticket provides to young women of color.
A day after the announcement, Biden framed his selection as providing little Black and Brown girls who often feel undervalued overlooked to have the ability to see “themselves for the first time in a new way. As the stuff of presidents and vice presidents.”
Taylor Swift says she is voting for Joe Biden and Kamala Harris this election
From CNN's Kate Sullivan
Taylor Swift attends the 2019 American Music Awards at Microsoft Theater on November 24, 2019 in Los Angeles, California.
Rich Fury/Getty Images
Taylor Swift said Wednesday she is voting for Joe Biden and Kamala Harris in this year’s presidential election.?
“The change we need most is to elect a president who recognizes that people of color deserve to feel safe and represented, that women deserve the right to choose what happens to their bodies, and that the LGBTQIA+ community deserves to be acknowledged and included. Everyone deserves a government that takes global health risks seriously and puts the lives of its people first. The only way we can begin to make things better is to choose leaders who are willing to face these issues and find ways to work through them,” Swift said in an interview with?V Magazine.?
Swift?tweeted?that she was going to be watching tonight’s vice presidential debate between Harris and Vice President Mike Pence.?
“Gonna be watching and supporting?@KamalaHarris?by yelling at the tv a lot,” Swift tweeted. She included a photo of herself holding her “custom cookies” decorated with the “Biden Harris 2020” logo.?
Swift broke her career-long silence on politics in 2018, when she endorsed two Democratic candidates in Tennessee who were running for the US Senate and House of Representatives. She spoke about her decision to weigh in on politics in the 2020 Netflix documentary, “Taylor Swift: Miss Americana,” in which she said she regretted not speaking out against Trump in 2016. In the documentary, Swift spoke out against Republican Sen. Marsha Blackburn’s conservative record and described her as “Trump in a wig.”
Link Copied!
These are the Covid-19 measures that will be in place at tonight's debate
From CNN's Dan Merica
Workers clean protective plastic panels onstage between tables for Vice President Mike Pence and Democratic vice presidential candidate, Sen. Kamala Harris, as preparations take place for the vice presidential debate at the University of Utah on Tuesday in Salt Lake City.
Patrick Semansky/AP
Mike Pence’s team agreed Tuesday night to allow the Commission on Presidential Debates to erect an acrylic glass barrier near the vice president for tonight’s debate in Salt Lake City, a Pence aide and commission member told CNN, bringing an end for now the negotiations over coronavirus safety precautions around the contest.
Pence’s team made it clear throughout the week that they thought putting any acrylic glass barriers near the vice president was unnecessary and that they opposed such a move.
Sen.?Kamala Harris’ team, however, wanted the acrylic glass barriers, in part, because of the ongoing spread of coronavirus inside the White House and the fact that Pence attended a Rose Garden event over a week ago that may have been?the genesis of the spread. Pence has since repeatedly tested negative for the virus.
Physical barriers are typically recommended when social distancing cannot be maintained. The candidates will be separated by 12 feet on stage. Masks are considered the best defense against both droplet and aerosolized transmission of the virus.
A member of the commission said the decision came on Tuesday evening, adding that there will now be two curved plexiglass barriers between Pence and Harris, one close to the vice president and one close to the California senator.
The commission member said the Pence team agreed Tuesday evening that “if (Harris) feels safer having it up on her side, they will leave it up on his side.”
Pence and Harris have tested negative for coronavirus ahead of tonight’s showdown.
Debate organizers are requiring that anyone in the hall other than the candidates and the moderator must wear a face mask, all of which came after they were advised to make changes by their medical advisers at the Cleveland Clinic.
Some debate background: The addition of the acrylic glass barriers to the debate tonight is the latest sign of how the ongoing coronavirus outbreak inside the Trump administration has reshaped the final month of the presidential campaign.
The health decisions made for the vice presidential debate tonight will certainly hang over the two future presidential debates — one in Miami on Oct. 15 and another in Nashville on Oct. 22.
Trump has said that he plans to show up for the forthcoming debates despite his positive coronavirus diagnosis, leading debate organizers to consider a host of contingencies for how to host each debate safely. One possible option is to?hold the debates virtually.
Pence and Harris face off tonight. Here are some key things to watch for.
From CNN's?Eric Bradner,?Gregory Krieg?and?Dan Merica
Getty Images
Vice President?Mike Pence?and his Democratic rival, Sen.?Kamala Harris?of California, will meet in Utah on tonight for the only vice presidential debate of the campaign.
Their showdown comes with the highest stakes for a vice presidential debate in recent memory, in part because President?Trump’s?coronavirus diagnosis has made it unclear if and how additional presidential debates will take place.
It will also mark a historic moment, as Harris becomes the first Black and South Asian woman to participate in a general election presidential campaign debate.
Pence and Harris share tickets with two of the oldest men to run for president — the 74-year-old Trump and the 77-year-old Democratic nominee, Joe Biden — putting an extra emphasis on their roles as the second in command.
Here are things to look for in tonight’s vice presidential debate:
Distance and acrylic glassbarriers: Even before the pandemic is mentioned at tonight’s debate, its presence will be obvious. Debate organizers, in response to the spread of the coronavirus inside the White House and the fact that Pence was at an event that was seemingly the genesis of the White House spread just over a week ago, made a number of changes to their safety protocols, including putting Pence and Harris more than 12 feet apart, using acrylic glass barriers between the candidates and requiring everyone in the audience wear masks. Pence’s team challenged the installation of acrylic glass barriers around him at the debate after the commission announced that they would be used, before ultimately agreeing to their installation. But their resistance highlighted how the Trump campaign wants to avoid the omnipresence of coronavirus and the worry among some in the President’s orbit that it could set a precedent for the forthcoming debates between Trump and Biden.
Harris’ challenge on coronavirus: Trump has tried to cast his Covid diagnosis and supposed recovery as a bonus. In his telling, he’s a fearless leader who took on the virus and triumphed — setting a model for bravery in the face of a pandemic. For Harris, the challenge is to use this massive stage and draw a line — clear enough for anyone to see and impossible to ignore — from Trump’s handling of the pandemic as President to the growing fiasco inside his administration. She must do this while the President’s own prognosis remains unknown. And even if, as Biden said on Monday night, his infection is largely the result of his own refusal to follow standard safety procedures, personal broadsides against him while he is battling the virus could carry some potential risk.
Pence needs to project calm: It has been a chaotic week for the Trump campaign, punctuated by the President himself testing positive for the virus and spending three days in the hospital but beginning with a frenzied debate between the President and Biden. Pence’s goals in tonight’s debate are to project a calm that Trump was unable to signal last week, while defending the administration’s handling of the pandemic and delivering the Trump campaign’s messaging that the virus should not dominate American life. It’s a difficult task: More than 210,000 Americans have died from the virus, small businesses across the country have been decimated and the prospect of more economic stimulus for Americans was rejected on Tuesday evening when the President urged Republicans to walk away from negotiations with Democrats, tanking the stock market. But Pence, according to people who know him well or have debated him in the past, is one of the most skilled politicians at redirecting a question to a topic he wants to focus on.
