Cruisers’ choice: Best cruise ships of 2019

Viking has conquered the small to mid-sized cruise ship market.

Viking Ocean Cruises, which was established in 2015, racked up 10 first-place awards in the 9th annual Cruise Critic Cruisers’ Choice Awards on Wednesday.

Viking’s long-established river cruise line also earned top honors, with Viking Vidar named best for river cruises in a new category.

The awards are based on consumer ratings and reviews posted to Cruise Critic over the past year. The world’s largest online cruise community, Cruise Critic features more than 350,000 cruise reviews, covering nearly 700 ships.

“At a time when travelers have a seemingly unlimited choice of which cruise to take – from the biggest and flashiest, to the most intimate and luxurious – there’s never been a better time to cruise,” says Colleen McDaniel, senior executive editor of Cruise Critic.

“But that also makes ship selection more important than ever. What’s really special about our Cruisers’ Choice Awards is that they’re based solely on ratings from cruisers themselves. And with so much changing in the cruise industry year after year – new ships, refurbishments, redeployments – these awards serve as a true finger-on-the-pulse of the industry, highlighting which ships are best serving their customers’ needs and expectations in real-time.”

The awards cover four ship size classes: large (2,000+ passengers); mid-size (1,200 to 1,999 passengers); small-mid size (400 to 1,199 passengers); and small (fewer than 400 passengers).

Cruisers' choice: Cruise Critic Cruisers' Choice Awards are based on consumer reviews and ratings on the cruising web site. Celebrity Equinox took top honors in 2019 for best cruise overall on a large ship.

Best cruise overall, mid-size ship: Oceania Cruises' Riviera earned best overall cruise in the mid-size category.

Best cruise overall, small to mid-size ship: Viking Sky was ranked No. 1 overall in the small to mid-size category.

Best cruise overall, small ship: Silversea Cruises' Silver Galapagos ranked first in the small ship category.

Best cabins, large ship: Royal Caribbean's Harmony of the Seas earned the No. 1 slot for best cabins among large ships.

Best cabins, mid-size ship: Oceania Cruises' Marina ranked first for cabins in the mid-size category.

Best cabins, small-mid size ship: Viking Sky earned honors for best cabins in the small-mid size category.

Best cabins, small ship: Paul Gauguin ranked No. 1 for best cabins in the small ship category.

Best dining, large ship: Celebrity Equinox was ranked first for dining among large ships.

Best dining, mid-size ship: Oceania's Riviera was ranked first for dining among mid-size ships.

Best dining, small to mid-size ship: Viking Sky was rated No. 1 for dining among small to mid-size ships.

Best dining, small ship: Windstar Cruises' Wind Spirit received the top slot for dining on small ships.

Best entertainment, large ship: Royal Caribbean's Symphony of the Seas earned the No. 1 slot for entertainment on large ships.

Best entertainment, mid-size ship: MSC Sinfonia ranked first for best entertainment among mid-size ships.

Best entertainment, small to mid-size ship: Viking Sun earned the top slot for entertainment in the small to mid-size category.

Best entertainment, small ship: Paul Gauguin Cruises ranked first for entertainment among small ships.

Cruisers pick their No. 1 ships

Prev Next

While Viking Ocean Cruises dominated first-place rankings among small-mid size ships – winning all but one top slot – Celebrity Cruises was the big winner among large ships.

Celebrity had five first-place wins. Caribbean-based Celebrity Equinox took four honors: best cruise overall, best cruise ship for dining, best public rooms and best value for the money. Another ship, Celebrity Eclipse, took the award for best service in the large ship category.

Silversea Cruises, Royal Caribbean, Princess and Paul Gauguin Cruises each earned four first-place rankings.

Oceania Cruises had three top slots. Oceania’s Riviera was named best overall cruise and was awarded for best dining in the mid-size category, and Oceania’s Marina was recognized for having the best cabins.

The number one best for families winner was Disney Cruise Line’s Disney Magic.

A Viking Ocean Cruises ship was named best for first-timers for the fourth consecutive year, with the 2019 honors going to Viking Sky.

First-place winners in select categories

Celebrity Equinox was ranked first for dining among large ships.

Best Cruises Overall

· Celebrity Equinox – Celebrity Cruises (large)

· Riviera – Oceania Cruises (mid-size)

· Viking Sky – Viking Ocean Cruises (small-mid)

· Silver Galapagos – Silversea Cruises (small)

Best Cruise Ship Cabins

· Harmony of the Seas – Royal Caribbean International (large)

· Marina – Oceania Cruises (mid-size)

· Viking Sky – Viking Ocean Cruises (small-mid)

· Paul Gauguin – Paul Gauguin Cruises (small)

Best Cruise Ships for Dining

· Celebrity Equinox – Celebrity Cruises (large)

· Riviera – Oceania Cruises (mid-size)

· Viking Sky – Viking Ocean Cruises (small-mid)

· Wind Spirit – Windstar Cruises (small)

Best Cruise Ships for Entertainment

· Symphony of the Seas – Royal Caribbean International (large)

· MSC Sinfonia – MSC Cruises (mid-size)

· Viking Sun – Viking Ocean Cruises (small-mid)

· Paul Gauguin – Paul Gauguin Cruises (small)

Best Cruise Ships for Shore Excursions

· Carnival Valor – Carnival Cruise Line (large)

· Coral Princess – Princess Cruises (mid-size)

· Viking Star – Viking Ocean Cruises (small-mid)

· Silver Galapagos – Silversea Cruises (small)

Best Cruise Ships for Value

· Celebrity Equinox – Celebrity Cruises (large)

· MSC Sinfonia – MSC Cruises (mid-size)

· Viking Sky – Viking Ocean Cruises (small-mid)

· Silver Galapagos – Silversea Cruises (small)